The Current State of Rugby
-
It's not just rugby it's all sports. I think it's a result of sports becoming more and more professional where it's all about the result.
Watch an nba game and see how they are constantly at the ref asking for fouls.
This idea of 'rugby values' is cringe worthy and laughable.
-
@Victor-Meldrew What did McDermott say?
-
@KiwiMurph said in The Current State of Rugby:
This idea of 'rugby values' is cringe worthy and laughable.
Not sure I agree with that.
There are values that rugby, rightly, prides itself on - respect for the Ref and vice-versa, supporters sitting together, players friendship and beers after the whistle, dirty & dangerous play and cheating pretty much frowned on.
-
@KiwiMurph said in The Current State of Rugby:
It's not just rugby it's all sports. I think it's a result of sports becoming more and more professional where it's all about the result.
100%
This idea of 'rugby values' is cringe worthy and laughable.
Agree, but also disagree - in that we should be using that "laughable idea" as a crutch to fight back against the "professionalism" (read: "cynicism").
Yes - it's always going to be a losing battle... but ... worth fighting.One thing cricket has going for it - is that whole "against the spirit of the game" being written into the base laws... so teams know that if they go too far... they can actually be slammed for it, no matter what other laws exist. Should be a foundational law in all sports.
-
@Victor-Meldrew said in The Current State of Rugby:
@KiwiMurph said in The Current State of Rugby:
This idea of 'rugby values' is cringe worthy and laughable.
Not sure I agree with that.
There are values that rugby, rightly, prides itself on - respect for the Ref and vice-versa, supporters sitting together, players friendship and beers after the whistle, dirty & dangerous play and cheating pretty much frowned on.
Johnny Sexton would beg to differ...
-
@Nepia said in The Current State of Rugby:
@Steve said in The Current State of Rugby:
faingaanuku et al
Who are the et al? Fainga'anuku is pretty much an anomaly, like a Piutau or a Lucky Luke from earlier generations.
All the sabbatical boys…
The likes of Mo’unga , Victor Vito, Laumape , Luatua.
Anyone with another World Cup cycle left in their legs really.
Stevenson is/was on the verge too apparently.
-
@Steve said in The Current State of Rugby:
@Nepia said in The Current State of Rugby:
@Steve said in The Current State of Rugby:
faingaanuku et al
Who are the et al? Fainga'anuku is pretty much an anomaly, like a Piutau or a Lucky Luke from earlier generations.
All the sabbatical boys…
The likes of Mo’unga , Victor Vito, Laumape , Luatua.
Anyone with another World Cup cycle left in their legs really.
Stevenson is/was on the verge too apparently.
Vito and Luatua were a rugby generation ago. The sabbaticals have been happening for years too. It's really not as bad as you're making out.
-
@taniwharugby said in The Current State of Rugby:
@Steve I'm not sure the empty stadiums are quite as much of an issue, however it may well be, as you say, it isn't a great look on TV, and with media painting a picture and then empty stadiums...?
I think the broadcast dollar rules, meaning the bums on seats matters little in that aspect, but rugby has moved off from being a big part of everyone's lives to people watching on TV if they don't have anything else on.
I know in my late teens-early 20s, a Friday night home game for northland was huge, we all went, smuggled a hip flask in, got sloshed and hit the town after
I personally haven't been to a super game for, I can't remember actually (but will probably be last time the Blues were up here, although don't think they have been here since 2013 which was my last super game at EP) but i go to every northland home game and the odd one away.
I watch club footy every week, so I still love the game, but I would say my interest from the top down has waned, particularly at super level, for the ABs, probably since 2019 things have been rocky in that relationship.
re the bums on seats, im just concerned...and i might be wrong....but im concerned that in the long run its just going to be harder to sell this product for big tv bucks if it looks like no one cares about it on screen, so whilst the dollars the ground generates directly are not as important...that is the representation of how good the game is...does that make sense?
agree with getting down to club games though, i enjoy them much more, ive documented on here finding a club in melbourne and managing one of their teams, i also think thats why i lament the disconnection the different levels, ive talked before about super games kicking off whilst clubs games are still underway literally making it impossible for rugby fans to watch the games
i just dont get the seemly deliberate attempt to separate local rugby communities from the professional end of the game
-
@Kiwiwomble said in The Current State of Rugby:
re the bums on seats, im just concerned...and i might be wrong....but im concerned that in the long run its just going to be harder to sell this product for big tv bucks if it looks like no one cares about it on screen, so whilst the dollars the ground generates directly are not as important...that is the representation of how good the game is...does that make sense?
agree with getting down to club games though, i enjoy them much more, ive documented on here finding a club in melbourne and managing one of their teams, i also think thats why i lament the disconnection the different levels, ive talked before about super games kicking off whilst clubs games are still underway literally making it impossible for rugby fans to watch the games
i just dont get the seemly deliberate attempt to separate local rugby communities from the professional end of the game
This must be a purely Australian location perspective in a Trans- Ta$man competition? Trying to watch NZ games starting at 5:30 local time?
Unless things have changed the last few years and I'm about to talk out of my arse (proving a point of Gourdie's article? I'm making a comment based on my opinions from about 5 years ago, because I no longer watch rugby and so don't have an 'informed' opinion on current scheduling ...)
For most of the last 20 years, in whatever guise SR has been in - In NZ there's usually only 2 NZ-based games per week and they are played respectively on Fri and Sat nights.
Which brings it's own problem I've banged on about for years. kids bedtimes ....
Whereas NRL, for e.g. Before they sold out for the TV money and brought in Monday night and Thuesday night etc etc, used to load their games on a Sunday afternoon. With single Friday night, Saturday afternoon, Saturday night matches for the TV (with a few out-of-NSW exceptions ). A benefit of having a comp that can schedule more than a measly 2 'home' games per weekend.
-
@Rapido its definitely an aussie problem but i think we need to stop looking at us and them and try and try and be more collaborative...or actually go it alone and have seperate comps
Its true though when i lived in chch, as someone without kids it was the standard line from mates with them when i asked if they wanted to go to a game....will have to come after bath/bed time so wont get there till after 730...so at most would go to the pub and watch
where as in the 90's i distinctly remember club games being moved to 12 kick offs so people could all go down to the brook and watch the Highlanders/all blacks at 2:35 (when games clashed), we use to put a bus on from kettle park up the road so everyone could get there
Stuff
