QF: Blues v Tahs

[Machpants]

Telea so good

[antipodean]

@Donsteppa said in QF: Blues v Tahs:

Thought they were quite brave in awarding that one outright...

That's the same AR that called the Zarn try too.

[Damo]

PT for me.

[nzzp]

@Damo said in QF: Blues v Tahs:

PT for me.

same

[nzzp]

@Damo said in QF: Blues v Tahs:

PT for me.

he reaches for it

[Kirwan]

@Damo said in QF: Blues v Tahs:

PT for me.

Sneaky on purpose, not on purpose IMO

[antipodean]

@nzzp said in QF: Blues v Tahs:

@Damo said in QF: Blues v Tahs:

PT for me.

same

Clearly accidental. He's never looing at the ball.

[akan004]

How could they award that? Embarrassing.

[nzzp]

@akan004 said in QF: Blues v Tahs:

How could they award that? Embarrassing.

was about to say that!

[Damo]

I think that is deliberate. I am surprised that PT has been ruled out so fast.

[taniwharugby]

Lam has been very good tonight

[Machpants]

No way that was deliberate, good call by refs

[hydro11]

No PT for me. I think you have to be sure it is foul play to award it.

[Kirwan]

Why pick that up?

[Victor Meldrew]

@Kirwan

Think the scrum was about to go down.

[taniwharugby]

@Kirwan I think picking it up was fine, but he should have passed it

[nzzp]

@hydro11 said in QF: Blues v Tahs:

No PT for me. I think you have to be sure it is foul play to award it.

including SBW batting a ball out of play when he could have caught it? THe standard is the standard - for me, that should have had a closer look, it was a sneaky 'oh look I kicked the ball' for me, kinda like 'oops I wound up on the wrong side of the ruck'.

[Machpants]

Lol Dalton going straight into the tahs front row, that's a penalty

[Damo]

@antipodean said in QF: Blues v Tahs:

@nzzp said in QF: Blues v Tahs:

@Damo said in QF: Blues v Tahs:

PT for me.

same

Clearly accidental. He's never looing at the ball.

I don't think it's clearly anything. It's marginal either way.

I am reminded of what an old law professor said to me about the word "clearly".

He said that one should never use the word "clearly" in submissions because if it the point is clear the judge will know it without you saying so - and if it is not clear your saying it is clear will not make it so.

[Mattasaurus]

Lam offers more than Clarke for me.