All Blacks 2023
-
The biggest problem with BB and RM in the Foster era is their territorial kicking and game management in the latter stages of a tight game. There have been numerous brainfarts at crucial times in tight games and the inability to grab the game by the scruff of the neck and play in the right parts of the field. Contrast that with the "McCaw golden years" of winning the tight ones. The semi-final against SA in 2015 was a classic example of that. SA couldn't get out of their own half for the last quarter of the game. The last Crusaders vs Chiefs game highlighted the RM problem. An absolute brainfart from RM handed the game to the Chiefs.
DMac is showing a big improvement in the areas mentioned but BB (who is a shadow of the player he once was) and RM keep doing the same old things. -
@Old-Samurai-Jack The flaws in the kicking games of BB and RM that you mention have always been evident in SR, but you can often get away with those inaccuracies in that level. Not so in tests.
-
@Old-Samurai-Jack said in All Blacks 2023:
The biggest problem with BB and RM in the Foster era is their territorial kicking and game management in the latter stages of a tight game. There have been numerous brainfarts at crucial times in tight games and the inability to grab the game by the scruff of the neck and play in the right parts of the field. Contrast that with the "McCaw golden years" of winning the tight ones. The semi-final against SA in 2015 was a classic example of that. SA couldn't get out of their own half for the last quarter of the game. The last Crusaders vs Chiefs game highlighted the RM problem. An absolute brainfart from RM handed the game to the Chiefs.
DMac is showing a big improvement in the areas mentioned but BB (who is a shadow of the player he once was) and RM keep doing the same old things.Which was the RM brainfart you mention? I thought Havili's bad defence read was the opening for the Chiefs
-
@Crucial That was the final part. RM had the opportunity to clear, instead went for the cross kick/defensive bomb that BB gets crucified for on here, they lost possesion not far from the 22 and Dmac was able to capitlise on DH's terrible read on defence.
-
@Kirwan said in All Blacks 2023:
@Crucial That was the final part. RM had the opportunity to clear, instead went for the cross kick/defensive bomb that BB gets crucified for on here, they lost possesion not far from the 22 and Dmac was able to capitlise on DH's terrible read on defence.
Just went and watched to remind myself. God yes that was awful!
Tight game, you've only just retaken the lead, in your 22 and need to get the ball down field.
He did have a numbers advantage out there initially but the height of the bomb allowed a whole load of Chiefs to get over there and disrupt any chance of a clean take. Dumb decision.
About the only leeway I'll give him was that he probably thought he was setting for a clearance on the full but as the pass came to him Gardner called 'taken back in' (correctly). His forwards had fucked up the exit. -
@Crucial said in All Blacks 2023:
@Kirwan said in All Blacks 2023:
@Crucial That was the final part. RM had the opportunity to clear, instead went for the cross kick/defensive bomb that BB gets crucified for on here, they lost possesion not far from the 22 and Dmac was able to capitlise on DH's terrible read on defence.
Just went and watched to remind myself. God yes that was awful!
Tight game, you've only just retaken the lead, in your 22 and need to get the ball down field.
He did have a numbers advantage out there initially but the height of the bomb allowed a whole load of Chiefs to get over there and disrupt any chance of a clean take. Dumb decision.
About the only leeway I'll give him was that he probably thought he was setting for a clearance on the full but as the pass came to him Gardner called 'taken back in' (correctly). His forwards had fucked up the exit.I am giving RM no leeway at all for this. He needed to exit and get the ball into Chief's territory. Another aspect to this is he is kicking it back to the best counterattacking team in the competition in open play, with the Crusader's defense in bits and bobs all across the park, their flanks exposed... It was a really dire decision.
DH shouldn't have been put in that situation in defense. -
@Old-Samurai-Jack said in All Blacks 2023:
DH shouldn't have been put in that situation in defense.
shocking, Dallin Watene-Zelezniak level decision making
But yes, the first and worst error was that shocking kick
-
Can you imagine if RM and DH did that in an AB test? Fozzie would get vilified.
-
@No-Quarter said in All Blacks 2023:
Can you imagine if RM and DH did that in an AB test? Fozzie would get vilified.
That’s because he doesn’t know how to use the Saders players properly though. Nothing to do with them being shit.
A decent coach would have got rid of that rubbish -
I think it is more concerning many in nz rugby use this as a tactic, too often.
Even if executed better most often it is a low % play anyway, but the execution is often not there as well.
I
-
@taniwharugby That includes the box kick up and under to exit your 22. I don't understand it because more often than not, you gift the opposition the ball in a prime attacking area and your defense is not set.
-
@Steve said in All Blacks 2023:
Will Jordan has 21 tries in 21 games for NZ aged 25.
He missed the end of last year but at that scoring rate he was/is easily going to break Howletts record.
I suspect he is already pencilled in to the RWC squad and he has been treated with kid gloves by the Crusaders under instructions from the higher ups at HQ.
He is back this weekend.
Hungry.
Angry.
Rested.Air Jordan about to cut lines like Tony Montana.
-
@No-Quarter said in All Blacks 2023:
@Victor-Meldrew said in All Blacks 2023:
@Steve said in All Blacks 2023:
@Victor-Meldrew said in All Blacks 2023:
@Kiwiwomble said in All Blacks 2023:
i find my self in the camp of its too late for players to prove themselves at international level those that already have (savea, JB at 12, tight five etc) great...
JB's played 3 (?) games at 12 so I'm not too sure he's proved himself at Test level. That said, he's probably the least-worst option in that position and just being solid and injury-free is a huge improvement on the midfield debacle of the last few years. Midfield is still the weakest area for me.
Agree on picking the best SR players but also take into account whether they can handle the step up. Don't need another Bridge to nowhere.
Midfield is definitely a cause for concern, especially when you factor in the amount of time Fickou, Ringrose, Aki, Farrell et al have had in the saddle.
I think having 2 big lumps in there is the least worst option to borrow your phrase.
Give me Jordie and Rieko over Havili and ALB any day of the week.
I hope you're right, but I have nightmares about JB being exposed as inexperienced by the likes of Ringrose etc. Just make sure JB gets as much game time as possible and pray he doesn't get injured.
I know JB hasn't had as much time as we'd like at 12 at test level, but he's had plenty of experience in the position during his career. He was also a HELL of a lot better than "solid" - I'd say the exact opposite, he was absolutely dominant in his performances there, easily the most influential player on the park and the best we've seen from an AB 12 since the days of Nonu. I'm far less concerned about our midfield then I am our 10.
Don't take calling his performance "solid" as a bad thing, as that's a really big step up from before and a real positive - particularly as he'd had little experience at the top level at 12 before stepping in at Test level
I guess I'm less convinced than you that he's been absolutely dominant at 12 but with the time he's had at 12 in SR, he should get better and better.
-
@Crucial said in All Blacks 2023:
@No-Quarter said in All Blacks 2023:
Can you imagine if RM and DH did that in an AB test? Fozzie would get vilified.
That’s because he doesn’t know how to use the Saders players properly though. Nothing to do with them being shit.
George Bridge is clearly the future post-Foster, then.
-
@Old-Samurai-Jack and that in part is due to our kick chase and contesting in the air not being great, this is where I think utilising the likes of Dagg & Jane in skills sessions would surely help, seems to be a gap in our skills for both attacking kicking game, and contesting/defusing kicks
-
@taniwharugby said in All Blacks 2023:
@Old-Samurai-Jack and that in part is due to our kick chase and contesting in the air not being great, this is where I think utilising the likes of Dagg & Jane in skills sessions would surely help, seems to be a gap in our skills for both attacking kicking game, and contesting/defusing kicks
I would guess that bomb defusing is a big part of skills training for back three players at most levels. To me the problem lies more with the communication and/or gelling between the 10 and the chasers. Teams that do that part well get the advantage and the defending jumper on a well placed and signalled kick is at a disadvantage.
Note the kick we have been talking about. The chasers didn't know it was coming meaning no one had an advantage and it became 50/50.
CJ, Dagg, Ben Smith were great under high balls partly because of excellent game reading skills and anticipation (hard to coach), partly because other teams didn't have that connection part down well on attack. I remember the Saffas getting very good at knowing when and where the ball would be kicked and it made our usually good aerial players look not so good. -
@Steve said in All Blacks 2023:
@nostrildamus said in All Blacks 2023:
@Steve said in All Blacks 2023:
Will Jordan has 21 tries in 21 games for NZ aged 25.
He missed the end of last year but at that scoring rate he was/is easily going to break Howletts record.
I suspect he is already pencilled in to the RWC squad and he has been treated with kid gloves by the Crusaders under instructions from the higher ups at HQ.
Maybe Jordan could move (finally) to 15?
That's the dream bro......We won't win it with Beauden Barrett doing cross kicks in his own 22.
Teams need to be afraid to kick it to us like the days of yore.
At the moment when they kick to us a territorial game of kick tennis ensues.
With Jordan there they might think "this mad kunt is gonna run it back from there with interest"
Look at the try against Wales or USA.
Having their fatties back tracking as a result of his line breaks will win us penalties too.
The boy is a scalpel.
Kick battles shouldn't be a hit and hope exercise though. Good kicking downfield can be used as a manipulative tool. It may appear like ping pong or handing the ball back but what you are trying to do is give the ball back in a compromising position. That could be from a chase that puts a kicker to their wrong foot. It could be with an expectation that they will kick back and you are setting up an opportunity for a run etc.
I don't think we have seen good tactical kicking from the back in the RM/BB era even if JB takes the clearance. I am worried that it isn't part of Jordan's game either.
I see it a little with Stevenson, I see it when DMac drops back and I see it from Zarn Sullivan. -
@taniwharugby said in All Blacks 2023:
I think it is more concerning many in nz rugby use this as a tactic, too often.
Even if executed better most often it is a low % play anyway, but the execution is often not there as well.
I
Not just NZ, club game on the weekend, had come back from 0-14 to be 19-21 with 5 to go....they were out of gas, just had to work out way back up field...and had three separate players try kick passes, grubbers or chip kicks....in our around or own 22!
-
I am sure everyone who played this game on the Fern would have been told if you kick it is to retain possession or kick into space not to hand unless it is contestable.
These days it seems just random kicking, can’t handle pressure so kick it no matter where it ends up or can’t break the defence/ or clearing hoof it down field and hope it lands in a good place.
Most teams have kicking coaches and attack and defence coaches what are they instilling in the players when it comes to kicking.
Where are the Carters,Mehrtens Fox’s etc should they not be used in some capacity as tactical kicking coaches.
