Reds v Brumbies

KiwiMurph

Between Blyth and Vest the Reds have some dumb second rowers.

Dan54

And there it is. The only outcome possible. Blyth's yellow has been upgraded to a red.

And there is a case where I think there should be a proper red, doesn't deserve a replacement.

Stargazer

@Dan54 According to the applicable guidelines, a straight red is only for deliberate foul play. Not sure how to prove intent. I assume this is more for things like throwing punches ...

Canes4life

Hahah Tate got monstered there.

Bones

@antipodean said in Reds v Brumbies:

I feel this is an excellent way to manage this (YC and review), but I'm surprised O'Keefe didn't go straight for a red card. I can't see how it's not.

Is he allowed to?

KiwiMurph

Quite enjoying the mayhem that the conditions are creating

Bones

Shades of Genia from Tate.

Dan54

@Stargazer said in Reds v Brumbies:

@Dan54 According to the applicable guidelines, a straight red is only for deliberate foul play. Not sure how to prove intent. I assume this is more for things like throwing punches ...

Yep I know what you mean, but absolutely dangerous play should also count. That wasn't just a mistake, it was real dangerous.

KiwiMurph

Petaia starting to put that potential on display the last month or so.

Bones

I take it Ikitau doesn't like McDermott.

KiwiMurph

Nice piece of skill by White

Bones

I do like Petaia's dedication to faking an injury anytime he does something shit.

Bones

Beautiful shape up and hands from the brumbies reserve prop.

KiwiMurph

Vintage Reds. Ill discipline and high error rate.

antipodean

Reds are so inaccurate, everything they do makes it easier for the defence and harder for themselves.

Dan54

@KiwiMurph said in Reds v Brumbies:

Vintage Reds. Ill discipline and high error rate.

Yep what I have been watching at Suncorp when I was living there. They just slow learners it seems.

KiwiMurph

@Dan54 said in Reds v Brumbies:

@KiwiMurph said in Reds v Brumbies:

Vintage Reds. Ill discipline and high error rate.

Yep what I have been watching at Suncorp when I was living there. They just slow learners it seems.

Time for a new voice at coach.

Duluth

Brumbies 52-24

I think it was 21-17 at halftime? So 31-7 in the second half

KiwiMurph

Now Reds have to go Samoa next week

antipodean

@KiwiMurph said in Reds v Brumbies:

@Dan54 said in Reds v Brumbies:

@KiwiMurph said in Reds v Brumbies:

Vintage Reds. Ill discipline and high error rate.

Yep what I have been watching at Suncorp when I was living there. They just slow learners it seems.

Time for a new voice at coach.

The drums must surely be beating now.

The Silver Fern

Reds v Brumbies