The Current State of Rugby
-
@Nepia im not sure how legit BBBR's clear out was though, trailing arm makes it look very shoulder chargy
-
@Kiwiwomble said in The Current State of Rugby:
@Nepia im not sure how legit BBBR's clear out was though, trailing arm makes it look very shoulder chargy
But that's partly my point, look at that tackle incident and how much a guy going for a legit tackle looks like he's going with both his shoulder and a swinging arm for good measure. (Not disagreeing with a card of some sort for both).
-
@Nepia said in The Current State of Rugby:
@Kiwiwomble said in The Current State of Rugby:
@Nepia im not sure how legit BBBR's clear out was though, trailing arm makes it look very shoulder chargy
But that's partly my point, look at that tackle incident and how much a guy going for a legit tackle looks like he's going with both his shoulder and a swinging arm for good measure. (Not disagreeing with a card of some sort for both).
Same as Koroibete's tackle style really. Hit's hard with the shoulder with the arm coming around after impact. Is ruled legal as he is 'using the arm'.
The whole thing about the use of the arm in a tackle in rugby was explained to me in the past (at coaching clinics) as a way to remove the 'point' of the shoulder. The point disappears when your arm comes up. -
Here's my current gripe of the game as I was harping on about in the ABXV game.
Listen to Nigel Owens at 4:10
and there's also a video that I can't find at the moment that highlights this happening in the second MAB/ Ireland game to TJP
The fact that firstly an international ref didnt understand it and YCd someone, then after review by WR everyone was told it was technically legal means that years of the halfback having protection at the base for the moment the ball leaves the ground to the moment they have it 'in possession' have disappeared.
Technically correct but the result when everyone does it is a shit show as we just saw in this morning's game. Once the ref ruled and explained that you can tackle or whack the 9s arm as soon as the ball leaves the ground the rucks became a mess until teams adjusted and slowed down the scrum by putting an extra layer in place.Now surely a 'loophole' like this shouldn't be encouraged by WR if it is detrimental to the game and creates negative and slow play?
-
@Crucial said in The Current State of Rugby:
Here's my current gripe of the game as I was harping on about in the ABXV game.
Listen to Nigel Owens at 4:10
and there's also a video that I can't find at the moment that highlights this happening in the second MAB/ Ireland game to TJP
The fact that firstly an international ref didnt understand it and YCd someone, then after review by WR everyone was told it was technically legal means that years of the halfback having protection at the base for the moment the ball leaves the ground to the moment they have it 'in possession' have disappeared.
Technically correct but the result when everyone does it is a shit show as we just saw in this morning's game. Once the ref ruled and explained that you can tackle or whack the 9s arm as soon as the ball leaves the ground the rucks became a mess until teams adjusted and slowed down the scrum by putting an extra layer in place.Now surely a 'loophole' like this shouldn't be encouraged by WR if it is detrimental to the game and creates negative and slow play?
I'll 100% disagree with you on this one.
Anything that incentives forwards to commit to a ruck is A OK in my book.
I thought it was great.
Rucks are inherently messy and are supposed to be messy.
-
@Crazy-Horse said in The Current State of Rugby:
@Frank said in The Current State of Rugby:
@His-Bobness said in The Current State of Rugby:
Meanwhile, in women’s rugby we see a glimpse of what used to be….
They don't have the power to hurt each other.
It"s relative isn't it? Compared to males they may be down on power, but I bet they can still hurt each other.
They're also that little bit smaller (I imagine) so less momentum.
-
-
@Steve said in The Current State of Rugby:
Scotland v Fiji kicks off.
60 seconds later we have our first yellow card.... Marvellous.
As long as Berry is consistent throughout the match I have no problem with it
-
@nostrildamus well it is clear they have a separate framework for women's head contacts and even lifting tackles...basically anything to avoid a card especially red, while the men's appears anything to find one.
-
@sparky said in The Current State of Rugby:
Be nice if World Rugby could get the refs to have some constancy in their interpretations of the breakdown.
Its all over the place. Barnes was blowing for penalties today at the breakdown and when I looked at him he had his arm extended towards the opposite team to who I had interpreted had infringed.
-
@Steve said in The Current State of Rugby:
@sparky said in The Current State of Rugby:
Be nice if World Rugby could get the refs to have some constancy in their interpretations of the breakdown.
Its all over the place. Barnes was blowing for penalties today at the breakdown and when I looked at him he had his arm extended towards the opposite team to who I had interpreted had infringed.
Barnes being the most experienced referee ever, he's probably correct most of the time
-
@Machpants said in The Current State of Rugby:
@Steve said in The Current State of Rugby:
@sparky said in The Current State of Rugby:
Be nice if World Rugby could get the refs to have some constancy in their interpretations of the breakdown.
Its all over the place. Barnes was blowing for penalties today at the breakdown and when I looked at him he had his arm extended towards the opposite team to who I had interpreted had infringed.
Barnes being the most experienced referee ever, he's probably correct most of the time
I had a chuckle when one of his first interactions with the game is his 100th was being hit with a pass. Must hold some record of getting in the way. His positioning has always been terrible.
-
@Crucial said in The Current State of Rugby:
I had a chuckle when one of his first interactions with the game is his 100th was being hit with a pass. Must hold some record of getting in the way. His positioning has always been terrible.
The poor pass from Smith that Frizell knocked on was also due to Barnes getting out of the way so late.
-
I don't want to see a red for Du Post or PSDT today.
PTSD was pushed by a team mate.
Du Pont had eyes on the ball the whole time and gets kneed in the face by a springbok who puts himself in danger by jumping.
I support neither team.
Game is gone to shite.
-
@Steve agree on the du Pont one, not the other, while I dont think it was filth or dirty as some have said, it was incredibly stupid and dangerous, I dont think his team mate pushing made any impact to his direction or how hard he hit the french guy
Oh, I will add, I dont agree with red cards sending you off for the rest of the game, and WR must find a better way to deal with this stuff.
-
-
@Bones it was pretty bad in that Cheslin landed pretty much on his head, failed his HIA i think, what Du pont didnt do, was jump, if he had leapt I think they were both in the space at the same time, both clearly able to contest, but du pont didnt jump, and went under Cheslin
-
-
@taniwharugby said in The Current State of Rugby:
@Bones it was pretty bad in that Cheslin landed pretty much on his head, failed his HIA i think, what Du pont didnt do, was jump, if he had leapt I think they were both in the space at the same time, both clearly able to contest, but du pont didnt jump, and went under Cheslin
I just can't buy guys running around a rugby field without a care of who's around or what's going on, especially at that level. It's not an excuse. To use another shitty analogy it's like jumping in the pool without looking. I mean, it's possible, but idiotic and you deserve anything coming your way if you fuck shit up.
