Foster, Robertson, Rennie etc
-
@frank said in All Blacks 2021:
Peter Umaga Jensen should have been picked despite an average Super rugby season.
I believe Hansen did that several times with players he deemed to be good fits for the ABs.
There's still time.
This may be unpopular, but Hansen (and Foster to a lesser extent) have struggled to bring in younger less-established PI players and turn them into long-term ABs, especially those who haven't gone through the 'character is king' Crusaders.
That list starts with Luatua, but also includes Piutau and others (Akira) who they've not been prepared to put time into and/or spend money on (had Hansen recognized Luatua's talent, we'd already have our Kaino replacement).
I personally would have picked PUJ ahead of Tupaea, who I think is good, but also a bit limited, and it was clear that we needed a 12/13 (which PUJ covers better than Tupaea).
-
@canefan said in All Blacks 2021:
@crazy-horse said in All Blacks 2021:
@kiwimurph said in All Blacks 2021:
@chris said in All Blacks 2021:
Your choice fuck 50 players can’t be all shit but 1 coach isn’t.
I don't think it's an either / or situation. Foster can be not up to it and the playing group can also be a problem - both can be true.
Yeah I think it's a bit of both. A few years ago the team picked itself, now every postion can be debated one way or another. So I don’t really blame Foster for the chopping and changing. Very few are demanding selection.
My memory tells me the year before the 1987 world cup the players and coaches sat down and decided they had to go to a more expansive game if they were to win the cup. They decided that they no longer had the players to win with the usual NZ style (very forward orientated). The NZ game as we know it now has evolved fom there.
Maybe it's time for another major re-think on how we play the game? We have fumbled along since the Lions.
I just don't know if Fozz is the man to change the mindset. He struck me as being a better assistant than a HC
Perhaps he'd make a good manager. The players like him.
-
@nostrildamus said in All Blacks v Ireland, 2021 NH Tour:
@dan54 said in All Blacks v Ireland, 2021 NH Tour:
@nostrildamus said in All Blacks v Ireland, 2021 NH Tour:
@dan54 said in All Blacks v Ireland, 2021 NH Tour:
@junior said in All Blacks v Ireland, 2021 NH Tour:
@old-samurai-jack said in All Blacks v Ireland, 2021 NH Tour:
My understanding is that Henry & co thought Razor wasn't ready because he needed to get out of his comfort zone here in NZ. Sir GH, just because you took that path doesn't mean it is the right path for everyone. Shouldn't GH have been put out to the retirement pasture due to the fact he is not neutral and is in fact quite cosy with Hansen and by extension Foster?
AND after the appointment of Foster, he goes and says Rennie was his favoured choice! FFS!Oh man that is a bit rich when you look at who got the job in the end
Man read the post, that was Junior's understanding, not what was actually said! man if someone puts on the net it's his understanding, don't get excited over it.
I'm not sure if you mean Old SJ not Junior but regardless yeah, GH shouldn't have said anything-obviously not impartial.
Well apart from a report in an Aussie paper, I don'r know if he did say anything. Boy talk about rumours becoming facts.
Henry is a great one for tongue in cheek, daughter was at a presentation by him through work, one of her workmates asked Henry what happened to the famous whitebait that Donald was catching when called up to the WC in 2011, his reply " Piri Weepu ate the all the fat bastard". Should we have an enquiry about that?Not unless whitebait play in or coach the All Blacks.
That is one of the weakest arguments by analogy I've read on the Fern, well done!
But Henry WAS at the panel AND did ask tough questions according to this article and Scott Robertson. IMO he was conflicted and should not have been there.
While Robertson told Greenwood, a former England and British and Irish Lions player, he didn't want to go into detail about the questions that put him on the back foot he offered a glimpse of how tough an adversary Henry could be in such a situation. "But it was probably around my decision making and he (Henry) challenged me on it," Robertson said on the podcast. "And what my thoughts (were) around why I was doing a couple of things and is that right … It was quite a challenging moment.All I can say is good for Graham Henry putting potential AB coaches on the spot. Not being there, but listening to Robertson's comments, you do wonder if he came across as a bit too confident. And no, that's not an endorsement of Foster's team.
As an aside, the missus of a Welsh friend is a headteacher who went to a non-rugby talk by Henry on the importance of sport and non-sport extra-curricular activities in schools. She said he was way ahead of the curve in his thinking on the subject and probably the best educationalist she has ever heard.
-
@victor-meldrew said in All Blacks v Ireland, 2021 NH Tour:
@nostrildamus said in All Blacks v Ireland, 2021 NH Tour:
@dan54 said in All Blacks v Ireland, 2021 NH Tour:
@nostrildamus said in All Blacks v Ireland, 2021 NH Tour:
@dan54 said in All Blacks v Ireland, 2021 NH Tour:
@junior said in All Blacks v Ireland, 2021 NH Tour:
@old-samurai-jack said in All Blacks v Ireland, 2021 NH Tour:
My understanding is that Henry & co thought Razor wasn't ready because he needed to get out of his comfort zone here in NZ. Sir GH, just because you took that path doesn't mean it is the right path for everyone. Shouldn't GH have been put out to the retirement pasture due to the fact he is not neutral and is in fact quite cosy with Hansen and by extension Foster?
AND after the appointment of Foster, he goes and says Rennie was his favoured choice! FFS!Oh man that is a bit rich when you look at who got the job in the end
Man read the post, that was Junior's understanding, not what was actually said! man if someone puts on the net it's his understanding, don't get excited over it.
I'm not sure if you mean Old SJ not Junior but regardless yeah, GH shouldn't have said anything-obviously not impartial.
Well apart from a report in an Aussie paper, I don'r know if he did say anything. Boy talk about rumours becoming facts.
Henry is a great one for tongue in cheek, daughter was at a presentation by him through work, one of her workmates asked Henry what happened to the famous whitebait that Donald was catching when called up to the WC in 2011, his reply " Piri Weepu ate the all the fat bastard". Should we have an enquiry about that?Not unless whitebait play in or coach the All Blacks.
That is one of the weakest arguments by analogy I've read on the Fern, well done!
But Henry WAS at the panel AND did ask tough questions according to this article and Scott Robertson. IMO he was conflicted and should not have been there.
While Robertson told Greenwood, a former England and British and Irish Lions player, he didn't want to go into detail about the questions that put him on the back foot he offered a glimpse of how tough an adversary Henry could be in such a situation. "But it was probably around my decision making and he (Henry) challenged me on it," Robertson said on the podcast. "And what my thoughts (were) around why I was doing a couple of things and is that right … It was quite a challenging moment.All I can say is good for Graham Henry putting potential AB coaches on the spot. Not being there, but listening to Robertson's comments, you do wonder if he came across as a bit too confident. And no, that's not an endorsement of Foster's team.
As an aside, the missus of a Welsh friend is a headteacher who went to a non-rugby talk by Henry on the importance of sport and non-sport extra-curricular activities in schools. She said he was way ahead of the curve in his thinking on the subject and probably the best educationalist she has ever heard.
This is what annoys me about the prevailing employment system we have at the moment- resume and interview. Sometimes I feel it comes down to who can do the best resume and who interviews the best rather than who can actually do the job the best. We can all think of people who keep getting jobs despite being useless.
Buggered if I know a better system though.
-
@victor-meldrew said in All Blacks v Ireland, 2021 NH Tour:
As an aside, the missus of a Welsh friend is a headteacher who went to a non-rugby talk by Henry on the importance of sport and non-sport extra-curricular activities in schools. She said he was way ahead of the curve in his thinking on the subject and probably the best educationalist she has ever heard.
He may have learnt that at Auckland Grammar from head John Graham who said extra curricular made the boys much better at planning their time etc.
But as to this "All I can say is good for Graham Henry putting potential AB coaches on the spot."
If he asked just as tough comments of Foster all good.
But as Shag worked for him and Foster worked for Hansen, it doesn't sit right with me that he was on the panel. -
@nostrildamus said in All Blacks v Ireland, 2021 NH Tour:
If he asked just as tough comments of Foster all good.
But as Shag worked for him and Foster worked for Hansen, it doesn't sit right with meWell if we rule out recent and previous coaches being involved in selection, you miss out on the expertise and if you don't allow those involved in the current coaching set-up to be chosen, it becomes even more of a lottery in choosing the best coach, I guess.
-
@victor-meldrew said in All Blacks v Ireland, 2021 NH Tour:
@nostrildamus said in All Blacks v Ireland, 2021 NH Tour:
If he asked just as tough comments of Foster all good.
But as Shag worked for him and Foster worked for Hansen, it doesn't sit right with meWell if we rule out recent and previous coaches being involved in selection, you miss out on the expertise and if you don't allow those involved in the current coaching set-up to be chosen, it becomes even more of a lottery in choosing the best coach, I guess.
I wonder how common it is to have recent coaches involved, actually. I suspect John Hart wasn't invited back..
-
@antipodean said in All Blacks 2021:
@chris said in All Blacks 2021:
@kiwiwomble said in All Blacks 2021:
@chris really all he gt right was the idea we dont have a 12...then it goes off the rails
There is more than that in the Article he got right amongst some BS.
That would be by accident. Reason's knowledge of and ability to write anything insightful about rugby is encapsulated in the infinite monkey theorem.
Runs in the family. You should have seen the drivel his dad used to write about Canterbury rugby.
-
@nostrildamus said in All Blacks v Ireland, 2021 NH Tour:
@victor-meldrew said in All Blacks v Ireland, 2021 NH Tour:
As an aside, the missus of a Welsh friend is a headteacher who went to a non-rugby talk by Henry on the importance of sport and non-sport extra-curricular activities in schools. She said he was way ahead of the curve in his thinking on the subject and probably the best educationalist she has ever heard.
He may have learnt that at Auckland Grammar from head John Graham who said extra curricular made the boys much better at planning their time etc.
If he asked just as tough comments of Foster all good.
who would know if he wasnt asked just as hard questions foster hasnt run to media tell .
-
@gt12 said in All Blacks 2021:
@frank said in All Blacks 2021:
Peter Umaga Jensen should have been picked despite an average Super rugby season.
I believe Hansen did that several times with players he deemed to be good fits for the ABs.
There's still time.
This may be unpopular, but Hansen (and Foster to a lesser extent) have struggled to bring in younger less-established PI players and turn them into long-term ABs, especially those who haven't gone through the 'character is king' Crusaders.
That list starts with Luatua, but also includes Piutau and others (Akira) who they've not been prepared to put time into and/or spend money on (had Hansen recognized Luatua's talent, we'd already have our Kaino replacement).
I personally would have picked PUJ ahead of Tupaea, who I think is good, but also a bit limited, and it was clear that we needed a 12/13 (which PUJ covers better than Tupaea).
Piutau fûcked off to Ulster. Nothing to do with the coaches.
-
@ploughboy said in All Blacks v Ireland, 2021 NH Tour:
@nostrildamus said in All Blacks v Ireland, 2021 NH Tour:
@victor-meldrew said in All Blacks v Ireland, 2021 NH Tour:
As an aside, the missus of a Welsh friend is a headteacher who went to a non-rugby talk by Henry on the importance of sport and non-sport extra-curricular activities in schools. She said he was way ahead of the curve in his thinking on the subject and probably the best educationalist she has ever heard.
He may have learnt that at Auckland Grammar from head John Graham who said extra curricular made the boys much better at planning their time etc.
If he asked just as tough comments of Foster all good.
who would know if he wasnt asked just as hard questions foster hasnt run to media tell .
If he can't answer hard questions in an interview, how's he going to cope in a situation Foster finds himself this week? More important to me was did he have a good answer to the question?
-
A question inspired by that article.
Doesn't anyone know what went on with PUJ? Was on the journey, played well enough to stick with at AB level then the Canes seemingly stuffed his progression. There was no big injury or scandal he just took ages to work his way back into being a key member of the side and that was the excuse to drop him for the ABs, opportunity lost.
Bad run of circumstances? Personal issues kept quiet? Niggling injuries?
Just seems weird looking back especially when the selectors then picked a bolter to take his AB squad spot.
-
@nostrildamus said in All Blacks v Ireland, 2021 NH Tour:
@dan54 said in All Blacks v Ireland, 2021 NH Tour:
@nostrildamus said in All Blacks v Ireland, 2021 NH Tour:
@dan54 said in All Blacks v Ireland, 2021 NH Tour:
@junior said in All Blacks v Ireland, 2021 NH Tour:
@old-samurai-jack said in All Blacks v Ireland, 2021 NH Tour:
My understanding is that Henry & co thought Razor wasn't ready because he needed to get out of his comfort zone here in NZ. Sir GH, just because you took that path doesn't mean it is the right path for everyone. Shouldn't GH have been put out to the retirement pasture due to the fact he is not neutral and is in fact quite cosy with Hansen and by extension Foster?
AND after the appointment of Foster, he goes and says Rennie was his favoured choice! FFS!Oh man that is a bit rich when you look at who got the job in the end
Man read the post, that was Junior's understanding, not what was actually said! man if someone puts on the net it's his understanding, don't get excited over it.
I'm not sure if you mean Old SJ not Junior but regardless yeah, GH shouldn't have said anything-obviously not impartial.
Well apart from a report in an Aussie paper, I don'r know if he did say anything. Boy talk about rumours becoming facts.
Henry is a great one for tongue in cheek, daughter was at a presentation by him through work, one of her workmates asked Henry what happened to the famous whitebait that Donald was catching when called up to the WC in 2011, his reply " Piri Weepu ate the all the fat bastard". Should we have an enquiry about that?Not unless whitebait play in or coach the All Blacks.
That is one of the weakest arguments by analogy I've read on the Fern, well done!
But Henry WAS at the panel AND did ask tough questions according to this article and Scott Robertson. IMO he was conflicted and should not have been there.
While Robertson told Greenwood, a former England and British and Irish Lions player, he didn't want to go into detail about the questions that put him on the back foot he offered a glimpse of how tough an adversary Henry could be in such a situation. "But it was probably around my decision making and he (Henry) challenged me on it," Robertson said on the podcast. "And what my thoughts (were) around why I was doing a couple of things and is that right … It was quite a challenging moment.Why should an experienced AB coach not be on panel of selecting another coach? And of course he should ask tough question on decision making, I would hope it asked of any coaching candidate. Hell man it's what happens in decent interview! They have to try and find weaknesses etc, and find what their plans are if they get the job. Hell you wouldn't want to of applied for coaching jobs even at u16 rep level in provincial level of the boards I was involved in if you didn't want to get challenged!
It was usual for candidates to get asked what they would do if and when things went wrong, and answers were how we rated coaches!
Unfortunately regardless of what we read on the net, it's not a popularity contest, but a decision on who the panel thinks will make the best job! -
@dan54 said in All Blacks v Ireland, 2021 NH Tour:
@nostrildamus said in All Blacks v Ireland, 2021 NH Tour:
@dan54 said in All Blacks v Ireland, 2021 NH Tour:
@nostrildamus said in All Blacks v Ireland, 2021 NH Tour:
@dan54 said in All Blacks v Ireland, 2021 NH Tour:
@junior said in All Blacks v Ireland, 2021 NH Tour:
@old-samurai-jack said in All Blacks v Ireland, 2021 NH Tour:
My understanding is that Henry & co thought Razor wasn't ready because he needed to get out of his comfort zone here in NZ. Sir GH, just because you took that path doesn't mean it is the right path for everyone. Shouldn't GH have been put out to the retirement pasture due to the fact he is not neutral and is in fact quite cosy with Hansen and by extension Foster?
AND after the appointment of Foster, he goes and says Rennie was his favoured choice! FFS!Oh man that is a bit rich when you look at who got the job in the end
Man read the post, that was Junior's understanding, not what was actually said! man if someone puts on the net it's his understanding, don't get excited over it.
I'm not sure if you mean Old SJ not Junior but regardless yeah, GH shouldn't have said anything-obviously not impartial.
Well apart from a report in an Aussie paper, I don'r know if he did say anything. Boy talk about rumours becoming facts.
Henry is a great one for tongue in cheek, daughter was at a presentation by him through work, one of her workmates asked Henry what happened to the famous whitebait that Donald was catching when called up to the WC in 2011, his reply " Piri Weepu ate the all the fat bastard". Should we have an enquiry about that?Not unless whitebait play in or coach the All Blacks.
That is one of the weakest arguments by analogy I've read on the Fern, well done!
But Henry WAS at the panel AND did ask tough questions according to this article and Scott Robertson. IMO he was conflicted and should not have been there.
While Robertson told Greenwood, a former England and British and Irish Lions player, he didn't want to go into detail about the questions that put him on the back foot he offered a glimpse of how tough an adversary Henry could be in such a situation. "But it was probably around my decision making and he (Henry) challenged me on it," Robertson said on the podcast. "And what my thoughts (were) around why I was doing a couple of things and is that right … It was quite a challenging moment.Why should an experienced AB coach not be on panel of selecting another coach? And of course he should ask tough question on decision making, I would hope it asked of any coaching candidate. Hell man it's what happens in decent interview! They have to try and find weaknesses etc, and find what their plans are if they get the job. Hell you wouldn't want to of applied for coaching jobs even at u16 rep level in provincial level of the boards I was involved in if you didn't want to get challenged!
It was usual for candidates to get asked what they would do if and when things went wrong, and answers were how we rated coaches!
Unfortunately regardless of what we read on the net, it's not a popularity contest, but a decision on who the panel thinks will make the best job!Yep, complaining about it publically comes across a little entitled really.
-
@crucial it's all very odd but I think it's just a case of Holland having his favourites and wanting Proctor on the park instead. Laumape had the 12 jersey locked down so it made it hard for Peter to break into the starting 15 knowing that Proctor had more of a backing, even though he was blatantly playing better rugby than Proctor and did an outstanding job in 2020.
Hopefully PUJ can take that 12 jersey with both hands next year and make a statement because he's shown he has the talent, he's arguably the most threatening midfielder in NZ on attack but defensively he probably needs to sharpen up a little.
-
@dan54 said in All Blacks v Ireland, 2021 NH Tour:
@nostrildamus said in All Blacks v Ireland, 2021 NH Tour:
@dan54 said in All Blacks v Ireland, 2021 NH Tour:
@nostrildamus said in All Blacks v Ireland, 2021 NH Tour:
@dan54 said in All Blacks v Ireland, 2021 NH Tour:
@junior said in All Blacks v Ireland, 2021 NH Tour:
@old-samurai-jack said in All Blacks v Ireland, 2021 NH Tour:
My understanding is that Henry & co thought Razor wasn't ready because he needed to get out of his comfort zone here in NZ. Sir GH, just because you took that path doesn't mean it is the right path for everyone. Shouldn't GH have been put out to the retirement pasture due to the fact he is not neutral and is in fact quite cosy with Hansen and by extension Foster?
AND after the appointment of Foster, he goes and says Rennie was his favoured choice! FFS!Oh man that is a bit rich when you look at who got the job in the end
Man read the post, that was Junior's understanding, not what was actually said! man if someone puts on the net it's his understanding, don't get excited over it.
I'm not sure if you mean Old SJ not Junior but regardless yeah, GH shouldn't have said anything-obviously not impartial.
Well apart from a report in an Aussie paper, I don'r know if he did say anything. Boy talk about rumours becoming facts.
Henry is a great one for tongue in cheek, daughter was at a presentation by him through work, one of her workmates asked Henry what happened to the famous whitebait that Donald was catching when called up to the WC in 2011, his reply " Piri Weepu ate the all the fat bastard". Should we have an enquiry about that?Not unless whitebait play in or coach the All Blacks.
That is one of the weakest arguments by analogy I've read on the Fern, well done!
But Henry WAS at the panel AND did ask tough questions according to this article and Scott Robertson. IMO he was conflicted and should not have been there.
While Robertson told Greenwood, a former England and British and Irish Lions player, he didn't want to go into detail about the questions that put him on the back foot he offered a glimpse of how tough an adversary Henry could be in such a situation. "But it was probably around my decision making and he (Henry) challenged me on it," Robertson said on the podcast. "And what my thoughts (were) around why I was doing a couple of things and is that right … It was quite a challenging moment.Why should an experienced AB coach not be on panel of selecting another coach?
-I explained why.
And of course he should ask tough question on decision making, I would hope it asked of any coaching candidate.
-I said that last sentence.
Hell man it's what happens in decent interview!
-As above.They have to try and find weaknesses etc, and find what their plans are if they get the job. Hell you wouldn't want to of applied for coaching jobs even at u16 rep level in provincial level of the boards I was involved in if you didn't want to get challenged!
-Robertson said he did appreciate a challenge. In the article I linked to.It was usual for candidates to get asked what they would do if and when things went wrong, and answers were how we rated coaches!
-I'm not disputing that.Unfortunately regardless of what we read on the net, it's not a popularity contest, but a decision on who the panel thinks will make the best job!
-Then people who have friends applying should excuse themselves from selecting.but a decision on who the panel thinks will make the best job!
-and the best person was Foster? -
@ploughboy said in All Blacks v Ireland, 2021 NH Tour:
@nostrildamus said in All Blacks v Ireland, 2021 NH Tour:
@victor-meldrew said in All Blacks v Ireland, 2021 NH Tour:
As an aside, the missus of a Welsh friend is a headteacher who went to a non-rugby talk by Henry on the importance of sport and non-sport extra-curricular activities in schools. She said he was way ahead of the curve in his thinking on the subject and probably the best educationalist she has ever heard.
He may have learnt that at Auckland Grammar from head John Graham who said extra curricular made the boys much better at planning their time etc.
If he asked just as tough comments of Foster all good.
who would know if he wasnt asked just as hard questions foster hasnt run to media tell .
-my point was he had an apparent conflict of interest. If he did ask similar hard questions of Foster (like, why his coaching record was weaker than the other candidates) then it shows he could rise above an apparent conflict of interest. But yes we will probably never know.
-
@nostrildamus
the most popular coach didnt get the job
still carnt see the conflict of interest. -
@ploughboy said in All Blacks 2021:
@nostrildamus
the most popular coach didnt get the job
still carnt see the conflict of interest.His mate's mate? That he defends publicly? Ok. Feel free to agree to disagree.
-
I'm genuinely struggling to see your point here (though to be fair I cant access the article due to geo-blocking).
An experienced bloke, Graham Henry, comes to an opinion on Foster having interviewed the other applicants and sticks to that opinion. Sounds pretty straightforward to me. Unless you don't want experienced people inputting into selection on the basis their successor has worked with a candidate, what do you think is the issue?
