2021 Rugby Championship
-
@machpants fair enough, akira probably gets there more on the first few games than the last couple
-
@kiwiwomble said in 2021 Rugby Championship:
@machpants fair enough, akira probably gets there more on the first few games than the last couple
Very true, I'd have Sia there instead (numbers rather tan position cheat!) Also I would have RIoane at 11, one of the players of the tournament.
Other wise pretty good. Not saying Scott should be there, but BBBR shouldn't
-
@machpants RI only played two games at 11 and his biggest contribution on the weekend was when he popped up in midfield
-
@kiwiwomble said in 2021 Rugby Championship:
@machpants RI only played two games at 11 and his biggest contribution on the weekend was when he popped up in midfield
Sure, team of the tourney, I don't care see he should be in it - Siya also
-
@kiwiwomble said in 2021 Rugby Championship:
thoughts?
They must have watched some different fixtures to me.
The most egregious selections:
4. Shadow of his former self. Hardly imperious and one of two standouts.
11. Did what apart from stand offside?
13. Never had the ball and if he did invariably coughed up.Most deserving are 12, 14 and 15.
-
@antipodean said in 2021 Rugby Championship:
The most egregious selections:
4. Shadow of his former self. Hardly imperious and one of two standouts.
11. Did what apart from stand offside?
13. Never had the ball and if he did invariably coughed up.Most deserving are 12, 14 and 15.
Spot on - I'd add 2. Taylor to the egregious list. He was shit, Marx way better, probably even the Wallabies hookers. Taukei'aho was very good the short while he was on the field, too.
-
@machpants said in 2021 Rugby Championship:
@kiwiwomble said in 2021 Rugby Championship:
thoughts?
Brodie there on reputation, Scott was better this series. Even with only one game, Aaron Smith still best 9
Pretty hard to pick a team of the tournament when there was such a merry go round of results, Argentina matches excluded. This is a team certainly picked from somebody whose main tournament viewing & analysis was all the Aussie games.
Hard to believe no Bok back row after the works of Kolisi, Smith & Vermulean against us.
Having said that, ultimately, as it's a team of the tournament, you should be looking at those players who did the most to get their players their board positioning. In that respect, then Akira Ioane is a no brainer. As is Kellaway, Cooper & Savea.
Zero interest in McDermott who I thought showed some serous potential against us, but then was erratic as all hell in other games. As for selections of Mapimpi & Am, they look like selections from somebody just trying to up the number of Safa's. Will Jordan the obvious candidate for me from his Aus / Arg results. Retallick shouldn't be there either, although I offer no viable alternative.
-
That's just a promotional mashup of names with vague justifications.
Agree that picking a definitive team is quite difficult given the swinging nature of performances across the tourney.
JB at 15 is fairly clear.
Kerevi also.
Fair argument for Cooper given the impact he brought to the team.
