Black Caps v Pakistan
-
WRT to the spinner selection - I'm still struggling with this from Stead:
*"The toughest squad selection was clearly around the spinner," said coach Gary Stead.
"That basically came down to the balance of the side and with the four-strong pace attack going so nicely we wanted to have a spinning allrounder as an option for that No 7 position."*
A guy that averages 25 (and scored 19 today) is a bowler (who is unlikely to take wickets in NZ).I think that we are living in the past a bit, our top order is so much stronger in NZ (mostly) and our pace bowlers so much fitter that giving them a rest with a spinner isn't really necessary either. So why not an attacking spinner that takes wickets (if one at all)?
-
@Snowy said in Black Caps v Pakistan:
WRT to the spinner selection - I'm still struggling with this from Stead:
*"The toughest squad selection was clearly around the spinner," said coach Gary Stead.
"That basically came down to the balance of the side and with the four-strong pace attack going so nicely we wanted to have a spinning allrounder as an option for that No 7 position."*
A guy that averages 25 (and scored 19 today) is a bowler (who is unlikely to take wickets in NZ).I think that we are living in the past a bit, our top order is so much stronger in NZ (mostly) and our pace bowlers so much fitter that giving them a rest with a spinner isn't really necessary either. So why not an attacking spinner that takes wickets (if one at all)?
When is De Grandholme fit again ?
-
@Snowy said in Black Caps v Pakistan:
WRT to the spinner selection - I'm still struggling with this from Stead:
I'm not. I'm really not convinced Stead is up to coaching this side. If anything I think he is a handbrake that Williamson is having to deal with for now. He was clueless in Aus and clueless when he went on holiday - he's not intellectually incisive enough to manage the team nor does he have the playing gravitas to persuade me either. Journeyman player - mediocre coach - the Santnav of Team management
-
Southee gives the haters more ammo with that innings.
With regards to the spinner dilemma. KW isn't the worst in the world when he actually has a go but is captaincy and being the best player enough for him to have on his plate ?
Watling's knack for scoring crucial runs when needed is obviously a big string to his bow but it's still almost a problem in how the side is selected around the 6/7 spots in the order. Do they go for another specialist batsman, shift Watling to 7 and hope that there are guys in the top order to roll the arm over occasionally ?
-
@MN5 said in Black Caps v Pakistan:
Southee gives the haters more ammo with that innings.
"Haters" = people with a different opinion to me.
Expressing the opinion that he should try just a little harder at his batting ...
transmission interrupted as Wags go... no he doesn't: no ball ... what a delivery though ...
... is hardly hating.
It was a great ball from Yasir though and chance of getting a wicket regardless (non-bouncing yorker) was extremely high.
-
Entertaining over from Shaheen.
Reviewing last ball lbw.
May be leg side.
-
@booboo said in Black Caps v Pakistan:
Entertaining over from Shaheen.
Reviewing last ball lbw.
May be leg side.
Way down leg
-
Ouchy foot for Wags. Could be a worry being his front foot for bowling.
-
@booboo said in Black Caps v Pakistan:
@MN5 said in Black Caps v Pakistan:
Southee gives the haters more ammo with that innings.
"Haters" = people with a different opinion to me.
Expressing the opinion that he should try just a little harder at his batting ...
transmission interrupted as Wags go... no he doesn't: no ball ... what a delivery though ...
... is hardly hating.
It was a great ball from Yasir though and chance of getting a wicket regardless (non-bouncing yorker) was extremely high.
He just get's a lot of grief for it that's all. He still has the talent to play the odd decent innings which is all that's needed sometimes.
-
@MN5 said in Black Caps v Pakistan:
@booboo said in Black Caps v Pakistan:
@MN5 said in Black Caps v Pakistan:
Southee gives the haters more ammo with that innings.
"Haters" = people with a different opinion to me.
Expressing the opinion that he should try just a little harder at his batting ...
transmission interrupted as Wags go... no he doesn't: no ball ... what a delivery though ...
... is hardly hating.
It was a great ball from Yasir though and chance of getting a wicket regardless (non-bouncing yorker) was extremely high.
He just get's a lot of grief for it that's all. He still has the talent to play the odd decent innings which is all that's needed sometimes.
He has (and had) the talent to play a lot of decent innings.
As I say though, you can't blame home for getting out to that.
-
@SynicBast said in Black Caps v Pakistan:
One of the problems that developped in the test team is that I don't think either Kane or McCullum had enough faith in any of the spinners to bowl them enough TBH. In McCullum's case, I don't believe he rated any spinner anyway so whoever got selected was on a hiding to nothing. This was exacerabted by the selection of the likes of santner and craig who arre basically seen - as vettori-lites. And let's be honest here, when was the last time Vettori ran through a test side - if my memory serves me well, it was before his batting became essential to make up for an extremely deficient top order
Disagree with this for Mccullum, agree for Kane.
Baz captaincy of spinners, Craig successfully, Sodhi unsuccessfully, was very positive.
Kane, not so much, unless he trusts them not to leak runs. His treatment of T Astle reminded Fleming 's captaincy of Wiseman.
-
-
The one who just got Watling.
-
@gt12 said in Black Caps v Pakistan:
The one who just got Watling.
Yup Afridi - I do not like his arm action when it comes to the short or effort ball - it looks distinctly suss
