I cant take Sky Sport rugby anymore - Any other options??
-
@Crucial said in I cant take Sky Sport rugby anymore - Any other options??:
@Rugby72 said in I cant take Sky Sport rugby anymore - Any other options??:
@Rapido Yes I agree, I really like Justin Marshalls insight, it's perfect for in game commentary during the live event.
Even I will admit that Meg's on the spot comments around some things is quite insightful. He has the vision to spot plays and tactics.
Someone just needs to gag him when there is a contentious rulingForget the contentious ones, it’s usually the fairly obvious ones he seems off script.
One thing in favour for Meg is that at least he’s willing to make a call on it. Not all ‘expert’ commentators do. Tim Horan for example is the greatest fence sitter going round.
-
@mariner4life said in I cant take Sky Sport rugby anymore - Any other options??:
@canefan said in I cant take Sky Sport rugby anymore - Any other options??:
@mariner4life said in I cant take Sky Sport rugby anymore - Any other options??:
@canefan said in I cant take Sky Sport rugby anymore - Any other options??:
@mariner4life said in I cant take Sky Sport rugby anymore - Any other options??:
@Rugby72 said in I cant take Sky Sport rugby anymore - Any other options??:
The smartest rugby minds in the world come from NZ
and they all have coaching jobs. Even some of the not so smart ones.
So you are left with the startling insight of Stephen Bates. I mean, look at the guys left to do media. Failed coaches. Players not smart enough to get coaching gigs.
They could at least balance them out with one or two professional sports journos if I would suggest anything....
and who are these professional sports journalists?
And keep in mind, a journalist is only as good as his access. And the NZRU have all the power there. And in a time when they control more and more of the content through their own platforms, it's only going to get worse.
Journalists don't add to panel shows either. Fox League have heaps of them on, and they are all deadshits. They are good for digging up dirt, and making confident faces while they air their guesses, but they don't know any more about how the sport is actually played than you or I. The same goes for the ones on the AFL shows.
I don't watch any of those shows anymore so I don't really care. I guess it isn't rocket science or tiddlywinks so who do we expect to front these shows?
i don't watch them either. As i don't care. Sport for me is entertainment, the detail just doesn't bother me. A test takes 2 hours, and that is the amount of viewing time i have to give it. I'll spend another hour typing here (and probably 4 reading!) but I'm not watching a panel show autopsy or preview because in all honesty, i'm going to get just as good from here, once i filter the bullshit (mainly my own)
The Fern fills a void in what @Rugby72 was getting at.
Maybe one for the grumpy old man thread, but build up pre-game shows are terrible and I’m talking across sports.
The only one I watch is Inside the NBA but that’s because Charles and Shaq are mainly talking smack and having a massive laugh. I’m not watching for their stats or analysis or gossip. Just a bit of fun and entertainment.
Rugby it’s dire. League blurg. The hosts are usually over excited and there to pat the backs and stroke the egos of the former players/coaches that are part of the commentary team.
At least on here you get a laugh, argument, insight, gossip, speculation; all stuff you can filter too.
-
@ACT-Crusader you're welcome.
-
@Crucial yea I used to always read his articles in the herald when he did them years back.
He'd be better suited to sideline or studio analysis rather than commentary where he is prone to those emotional outbursts or ridiculous off the cuff comments that are often wrong.
-
-
@mofitzy_ said in I cant take Sky Sport rugby anymore - Any other options??:
Wish they did more tactical analysis or player head to heads. I actually don't mind Goldie, JK, Marshall but some of the B-team (Bates, Wheeler etc.) are a bore. I would rather have mush mouth Jones.
Goldie, JK, Marshall
Time for grumpy old man thread. Goldie is inoffensive, but knows who butters his bread (NZRugby - everything is awesome).
JK's insight and analysis capability is remarkably low for someone who coached at the top level. Remarkable human being, but as an insightful commentator is terrible. 'The boys will be up for it this week'. FFS, thanks Einstein.
Marshall has that halfback quality of being totally confident, and often totally wrong. I get you need that to succeed at the top level, but learn the goddamn laws and don't spout off when you're totally wrong. Again.
-
Goldie and Marshall are underutilized. Ex players who are unflustered in front of the camera. For this reason I think Goldie is wasted as host.
4 people on a show is too many. Should be host plus 2 experts.
Never, never, ever make people stand, with a tablet, and talk. Warning bells right there that show will be fluff over quality.
Standing in front of big screen only to be a medium when need to point, like the hat guy on 1014 .
-
@nzzp said in I cant take Sky Sport rugby anymore - Any other options??:
@mofitzy_ said in I cant take Sky Sport rugby anymore - Any other options??:
Wish they did more tactical analysis or player head to heads. I actually don't mind Goldie, JK, Marshall but some of the B-team (Bates, Wheeler etc.) are a bore. I would rather have mush mouth Jones.
Goldie, JK, Marshall
Time for grumpy old man thread. Goldie is inoffensive, but knows who butters his bread (NZRugby - everything is awesome).
JK's insight and analysis capability is remarkably low for someone who coached at the top level. Remarkable human being, but as an insightful commentator is terrible. 'The boys will be up for it this week'. FFS, thanks Einstein.
Marshall has that halfback quality of being totally confident, and often totally wrong. I get you need that to succeed at the top level, but learn the goddamn laws and don't spout off when you're totally wrong. Again.
This rant is outstanding
-
IMO Marshall is at his best when there is a set piece and he calmly dissects what the attacking options are, where he expects the play to go for the next phase or 2.
I also don't mind when he gets a bit excited, even though his comments are less valuable, its still clear he just loves the game and the ABs.
-
I think a lot of rugby commentary has gone to shit because with all the angles and replays and such there is nothing to talk about.
The only cure is to A) see if there is a radio broadcast running in parallel (like people do here in Oz with ABC Radio during the cricket) or
just stick it out and then go and find interesting analyses like Squide Rugby afterward. -
@voodoo said in I cant take Sky Sport rugby anymore - Any other options??:
IMO Marshall is at his best when there is a set piece and he calmly dissects what the attacking options are, where he expects the play to go for the next phase or 2.
I also don't mind when he gets a bit excited, even though his comments are less valuable, its still clear he just loves the game and the ABs.
Only thing being he gets the play wrong so many times...
-
@Bones said in I cant take Sky Sport rugby anymore - Any other options??:
@voodoo said in I cant take Sky Sport rugby anymore - Any other options??:
IMO Marshall is at his best when there is a set piece and he calmly dissects what the attacking options are, where he expects the play to go for the next phase or 2.
I also don't mind when he gets a bit excited, even though his comments are less valuable, its still clear he just loves the game and the ABs.
Only thing being he gets the play wrong so many times...
deliberate misdirection because the oppo coaches are listening in ...😉
