Otago v Auckland
-
@Kirwan said in Otago v Auckland:
@Kiwiwomble said in Otago v Auckland:
@Kirwan said in Otago v Auckland:
@Kiwiwomble said in Otago v Auckland:
why dont we just give a PT straight away, why bother with a scrum
???!? We beasted the scrum and it fell apart under the posts. Have seen plenty of similar PTs
yeah, but otago didnt stop the auckland scrum from progressing, they stayed engaged, didn't collapse...so if you have a dominant scrum the only option are
A) auckland stuff up and knock it on
B ) Auckland score a try
C) penalty try...not exactly a contest anymore is it, just give a fing try and move on, guys cant suddenly get stronger can they so no other options
Or stay in a scrum formation, stay up, and stay straight. Don’t do those things, bad things happen.
ok...im just not going to reply other than this because i can see your just trying to wind me up
-
@Kiwiwomble said in Otago v Auckland:
@Kirwan said in Otago v Auckland:
@Kiwiwomble said in Otago v Auckland:
@Kirwan said in Otago v Auckland:
@Kiwiwomble said in Otago v Auckland:
why dont we just give a PT straight away, why bother with a scrum
???!? We beasted the scrum and it fell apart under the posts. Have seen plenty of similar PTs
yeah, but otago didnt stop the auckland scrum from progressing, they stayed engaged, didn't collapse...so if you have a dominant scrum the only option are
A) auckland stuff up and knock it on
B ) Auckland score a try
C) penalty try...not exactly a contest anymore is it, just give a fing try and move on, guys cant suddenly get stronger can they so no other options
Or stay in a scrum formation, stay up, and stay straight. Don’t do those things, bad things happen.
ok...im just not going to reply other than this because i can see your just trying to wind me up
Genuinely not. Otago are just struggling against a better scrum. Ref has been fine in this area
-
@Kiwiwomble Did you watch the scrum replay? They had splintered.
-
ok, other than getting stronger, how do you think a scrum can do anythign more than they did, still bound and in formation...just standing because of the fing stonger scrum
-
If you actually watch Ruru for a good period of time, he undoes one of 2 very good things with many poor options and when you consider he is behind dominant sizeable pack ..have watched young Funaki from Marist and Tusitala from Ponies..why would persist with this guy..?
-
@Tim said in Otago v Auckland:
@Kiwiwomble Did you watch the scrum replay? They had splintered.
still arms around each otterther and nothign had stopped auckland walking over the line
-
@Kiwiwomble said in Otago v Auckland:
@Tim said in Otago v Auckland:
@Kiwiwomble Did you watch the scrum replay? They had splintered.
still arms around each otterther and nothign had stopped auckland walking over the line
Probably about to get an action replay
-
I don’t mind him getting first chance. Hopefully Funaki gets a start soon though
-
@Kiwiwomble It's harder to control the ball when the opposition scrum starts going sideways.
-
@Tim what more do you want, at the 8's feet over the line
-
@Kiwiwomble said in Otago v Auckland:
@Tim what more do you want, at the 8's feet over the line
Penalty advantage for all the previous infringements?
-
@Kirwan said in Otago v Auckland:
@Kiwiwomble said in Otago v Auckland:
@Tim what more do you want, at the 8's feet over the line
Penalty advantage for all the previous infringements?
thst would be the winding up shit i was talking about
-
@Kiwiwomble said in Otago v Auckland:
@Kirwan said in Otago v Auckland:
@Kiwiwomble said in Otago v Auckland:
@Tim what more do you want, at the 8's feet over the line
Penalty advantage for all the previous infringements?
thst would be the winding up shit i was talking about
Or pointing out the penalty offenses you are ignoring?
-
@Kiwiwomble It's an interesting question as to whether it stops the try, and whether that's enough for a penalty try. Similar to the way mauls are reffed?
-
@Kirwan said in Otago v Auckland:
@Kiwiwomble said in Otago v Auckland:
@Kirwan said in Otago v Auckland:
@Kiwiwomble said in Otago v Auckland:
@Tim what more do you want, at the 8's feet over the line
Penalty advantage for all the previous infringements?
thst would be the winding up shit i was talking about
Or pointing out the penalty offenses you are ignoring?
not ignoring, not relevant, otago werent nder any scrum warnings, that scrum was still up and just walked over the line
-
@Kirwan said in Otago v Auckland:
See it can be defended
what people say about you is true, playing the innocent about winding up and then straight up doing it
