Sam Cane - All Blacks Captain
-
Would have loved to see Dane Coles as AB skipper as he is such a focused and intense player and an inspirational captain, but age and some ill-discipline count against him.
Sam Cane, super reliable, great team man and regularly tops tackle count, also seems to give at least a 7/10 performance every match. It was madness to leave him out of the starting XV for the 2019 semi.
Sam Whitelock was a great AB but faded somewhat in 2018 and 2019, didn't perform especially were at RWC. Seemed tired after long Crusaders season. The OE might freshen him up. Perhaps he might benefit from a move to another Super Franchise?
-
@sparky said in Sam Cane - All Blacks Captain:
Would have loved to see Dane Coles as AB skipper as he is such a focused and intense player and an inspirational captain, but age and some ill-discipline count against him.
Sam Cane, super reliable, great team man and regularly tops tackle count, also seems to give at least a 7/10 performance every match. It was madness to leave him out of the starting XV for the 2019 semi.
Sam Whitelock was a great AB but faded somewhat in 2018 and 2019, didn't perform especially were at RWC. Seemed tired after long Crusaders season. The OE might freshen him up. Perhaps he might benefit from a move to another Super Franchise?
We don't want him at the Canes. WAAAAAAAAAAYYYYYYY too tall and good, in fact completely against the Canes ethos of playing short journeymen dating back to Fish Tito and Fluke Andrews.
-
@MN5 I actually thought the Fish and Andrews were tall compared with your recent offerings? I mean they were both taller than 1.96m at least right?
On Ardie, I think he's up to test rugby, even though I agree with @mariner4life's post about Cane. I'm happy for the two of them to play together, it was actually working pretty well before Hansen bottled it for the England test. It's good to have contrasting styles. It just depends on who we get for the other position. I also think that Ardie coming off the bench, like he used to is great from a tactical point of view. Just don't ever bench the guy who can blunt an early onslaught the most effectively.
Anyway, isn't Ardie going to be playing for the Storm/Roosters this time next year?
-
-
I made the mistake of reading comments on the All Blacks Facebook announcement. Anyone labouring under the belief New Zealanders are knowledgeable about rugby should read those. We're geniuses in comparison.
-
@akan004 said in Sam Cane - All Blacks Captain:
@nzzp Just wondering why SA wouldn't have their Northern Hemisphere starts to pick from? Have they changed their selection policy or are you basing this on the potential impact of Covid?
I may be wrong, but my understanding was that both SA and Aus selected a bunch of players out of the NH specifically for the RWC.
If they don't you run into seasonal issues; travel, conditioning, etc. But hey - you coudl be right; we may get those players selected again soon. Great for international rugby, not so good for the players, terrible for clubs
-
@antipodean said in Sam Cane - All Blacks Captain:
I made the mistake of reading comments on the All Blacks Facebook announcement. Anyone labouring under the belief New Zealanders are knowledgeable about rugby should read those. We're geniuses in comparison.
What is the mood there?
-
@nzzp said in Sam Cane - All Blacks Captain:
@akan004 said in Sam Cane - All Blacks Captain:
@nzzp Just wondering why SA wouldn't have their Northern Hemisphere starts to pick from? Have they changed their selection policy or are you basing this on the potential impact of Covid?
I may be wrong, but my understanding was that both SA and Aus selected a bunch of players out of the NH specifically for the RWC.
If they don't you run into seasonal issues; travel, conditioning, etc. But hey - you coudl be right; we may get those players selected again soon. Great for international rugby, not so good for the players, terrible for clubs
Australia didn't, but are reviewing the Giteau rule (lower caps minimum or get rid), SA got rid of the no overseas limit totally.
-
@antipodean said in Sam Cane - All Blacks Captain:
I made the mistake of reading comments on the All Blacks Facebook announcement. Anyone labouring under the belief New Zealanders are knowledgeable about rugby should read those. We're geniuses in comparison.
Yeah I read a few as well.
Cieran Reid was a much better captain than Sam Kane will ever be apparently.......
-
-
@nzzp said in Sam Cane - All Blacks Captain:
@MN5 said in Sam Cane - All Blacks Captain:
Cieran Reid was a much better captain than Sam Kane will ever be apparently.......
Isn't Kane a black cap?
Indeed he is but I'm deeply offended at the 25% correct spelling rate of this All Black fan......
-
@canefan said in Sam Cane - All Blacks Captain:
@antipodean said in Sam Cane - All Blacks Captain:
I made the mistake of reading comments on the All Blacks Facebook announcement. Anyone labouring under the belief New Zealanders are knowledgeable about rugby should read those. We're geniuses in comparison.
What is the mood there?
Mostly supportive, but too may complaining that he's not the best flanker we have, that he's not smart enough to be captain. Then there's those upset that despite no rugby at the moment, they've decided to announce him as captain.
Just too many retards.
-
@antipodean said in Sam Cane - All Blacks Captain:
@canefan said in Sam Cane - All Blacks Captain:
@antipodean said in Sam Cane - All Blacks Captain:
I made the mistake of reading comments on the All Blacks Facebook announcement. Anyone labouring under the belief New Zealanders are knowledgeable about rugby should read those. We're geniuses in comparison.
What is the mood there?
Mostly supportive, but too may complaining that he's not the best flanker we have, that he's not smart enough to be captain. Then there's those upset that despite no rugby at the moment, they've decided to announce him as captain.
Just too many retards.
I'll give that a wide berth then
-
-
Really sucks we don't have any AB rugby to look forward to right now.
Cane is a good choice, I've always favoured him over Whitelock. He has a bit of McCaw about him with his sheer determination that would inspire the others.
On Ardie - I really like him at 8 and would be happy with 6. Big Bopper / 7. Cane / 8. Ardie.
I actually think Ardie will go better at 8 than Read did for his last couple of seasons. He's explosive with ball in hand and can play a wider game there while our 6/7 keep it tight - that worked perfectly when Read was in his prime.
I don't think he should play 6 and he should never in a thousand years have started at 7 over Cane against a team whose only fucking plan of attack was to beat us up in the forwards. Jesus Christ that was some braindead shit from the coaches.
-
-
@Marty said in Sam Cane - All Blacks Captain:
@Bovidae said in Sam Cane - All Blacks Captain:
Another reminder why I avoid FB.
I assume Richard Knowler had to rewrite his latest article last night.
And Hamish Bidwell is going to lose his shit ...
Excellent!
-
Has anyone got a live stream link to mariner4life being crucified? Asking for a friend.
-
@Billy-Tell said in Sam Cane - All Blacks Captain:
Has anyone got a live stream link to mariner4life being crucified? Asking for a friend.
sicko!
-
A team hasn’t been named for the first AB test and there’s already too many Chiefs
