RWC: Japan v Samoa (Pool A)

[Damo]

@ACT-Crusader said in RWC: Japan v Samoa (Pool A):

@Damo what’s the ruling around ball strips? I see variable rulings on this.

Take that last one where a Samoan player rips it out of Matushima’s hands and Peyper rules a knock on against Japan.

Whereas I’ve seen it ruled as play on because it was the defensive player that takes it out of the hands of the attacking one.

My view is that a strip backwards shouldn't be a knock on unless the last hands it touches is the ball carriers.

[voodoo]

@Damo said in RWC: Japan v Samoa (Pool A):

@chimoaus said in RWC: Japan v Samoa (Pool A):

Kind of sad each match thread is dominated by the laws and not the game itself.

Ordinarily yes, but this is an interesting point. And the discussion has been civil and thoughtful.

I dont bring much value to this forum, but I'll claim this :face_with_stuck-out_tongue:

[Nevorian]

why did it take them 10 minutes to get Nanai-Williams off for a HIA?

[Damo]

Josh Ioane with another late tackle. That one was probably just OK, but sheesh.

[Stargazer]

TJ Ioane must really be careful with his tackles. That one was late. Not spotted/penalised.

[Damo]

TJ Ioane rather than Josh.

[voodoo]

@Damo said in RWC: Japan v Samoa (Pool A):

Josh Ioane with another late tackle. That one was probably just OK, but sheesh.

Agree, if the attacker had milked that, I think it would have been reviewed. V lucky

[Victor Meldrew]

Dumb penalty from Samoa

[Victor Meldrew]

Gotta love the Japanese fans

[chimoaus]

Is it just me or does the crowd go like statues when a player is kicking for goal?

[MiketheSnow]

Now that's a driving maul 👏👏👏

[chimoaus]

Beautiful rolling maul try to Japan, are Samoa getting tired?

[voodoo]

@MiketheSnow

I'm not sure there has been a moment that encapsulates a team on the rise v a team on the decline like that.

[KiwiMurph]

Himeno is a really good loosie.

[ACT Crusader]

Great crowd reaction to the drive.

Samoa have looked good ball in hand but just when they get a roll on the pass from the midfield out has been terrible. Hard pass / bad timing of runner.

[Damo]

@voodoo said in RWC: Japan v Samoa (Pool A):

@MiketheSnow

I'm not sure there has been a moment that encapsulates a team on the rise v a team on the decline like that.

And well coached. They threw it long so all the backs could join in immediately. This Japanese team is very well drilled.

[ACT Crusader]

Samoa have woken up.

[Damo]

Bordering on a YC there. Multiple offsides in the redzone.

[MiketheSnow]

Excellent defence

[MiketheSnow]

Crowd goes wild