SF Crusaders v Chiefs
-
@ACT-Crusader said in SF Crusaders v Chiefs:
@KiwiPie said in SF Crusaders v Chiefs:
@booboo said in SF Crusaders v Chiefs:
What the FUCK was PGS doing when he did everything he could not to score? Fucking seriously.
Massive guy, try line in front of him, defender not in front of him, ponders his options and decides to look for a pass inside. Very strange.
The pressure of finals footy! MMT would’ve scored that. Yes I am on that bandwagon 😉
About 10 others would have as well. Including some retired 15 years.
-
I haven't read the thread, but a couple of thoughts from me:
(1) The Chiefs will be very disappointed when they review the video as this was a lost opportunity with try-scoring chances squandered. None more so than Sowakula losing the ball over the goal line, and a poor pass from Tupaea with Nankivell unmarked.
(2) Despite all of the possession the Chiefs backs never looked that dangerous. The fault here lies mostly with Weber, Gatland and Ioane. Too many inaccurate passes from Weber putting first receivers under pressure which was often led to by mistakes further out (e.g., the Gatland intercept). The ball needed to be moved quicker to stretch the Crusaders defence but the ball was so slow it made defending that much easier. Ioane running sideways didn't help anyone.
(3) This game showed why I have never been on the Sowakula AB bandwagon. He basically shat the bed and should have been subbed off instead of Finau. He still makes too many basic errors for my liking and I'll take Jacobson at no.8 for the Chiefs every time.
(4) Ross and Ta'avao did their AB chances no harm as they dominated their opponents in the scrum, although both made a crucial mistake leading to tries.
-
-
@kiwi_expat we are still underdogs…
Would be good if the Brumbies win tonight so we’ll have a fighters chance next week. Blues win and we have to travel to Eden Park, we might as well just take in the Auckland sights.
-
This post is deleted!
-
@Canes4life said in SF Crusaders v Chiefs:
Can Robertson just take Foster’s place already.
Yep, Incredible defense. Every Crusaders player knew what to do in every situation. Their line speed in defence, the outside defender coming up quicker to shut wide play down, only three max in the tackle, another defensive line quickly forming behind the ruck, and great communication. Then rinse and repeat. Brilliant coaching, Robertson surely has the best defensive set-up in the Southern Hemisphere.
-
Samisoni is an absolute superstar in the making. The most exciting prospect we have at the moment.
-
D Duluth forked this topic on
-
It was a really good defensive effort by the Crusaders but it relied on a massive dose of the Chiefs not being able to finish off the chances that they had.
It reminded me of the AB's defensive effort against Ireland last year where the AB's made 200 odd tackles and multiple players going 20+ on the tackle count. The big difference here was that the Irish took their chances and got points on the board.
Not trying to take anything away from the Crusaders as it was a good win. I'm just not sure the defensive blueprint can be relied upon at international level.
-
@kiwi_expat said in SF Crusaders v Chiefs:
@Canes4life said in SF Crusaders v Chiefs:
Can Robertson just take Foster’s place already.
Yep, Incredible defense. Every Crusaders player knew what to do in every situation. Their line speed in defence, the outside defender coming up quicker to shut wide play down, only three max in the tackle, another defensive line quickly forming behind the ruck, and great communication. Then rinse and repeat. Brilliant coaching, Robertson surely has the best defensive set-up in the Southern Hemisphere.
A big part of this is ruck judgement. If ball not obvious to be won, Chch is excellent at clearing their players out so arguably the ruck has ended. I'm not sure where the offside line is in such instances but they appear to line up parallel with the foremost opposition player. So in practice, perhaps 2m downfield from where the halfback picks up the ball.
By the time the ball gets to the oppo first five Chch defense is over the advantage line.
Really makes it difficult to impossible to get go forward from slow ball.
My gut tells me the offside line needs to be moved further back, but not sure exactly how to achieve that.
Maybe make it 5m back from front of first oppo player at the ruck which was?
-
@pakman said in SF Crusaders v Chiefs:
@kiwi_expat said in SF Crusaders v Chiefs:
@Canes4life said in SF Crusaders v Chiefs:
Can Robertson just take Foster’s place already.
Yep, Incredible defense. Every Crusaders player knew what to do in every situation. Their line speed in defence, the outside defender coming up quicker to shut wide play down, only three max in the tackle, another defensive line quickly forming behind the ruck, and great communication. Then rinse and repeat. Brilliant coaching, Robertson surely has the best defensive set-up in the Southern Hemisphere.
A big part of this is ruck judgement. If ball not obvious to be won, Chch is excellent at clearing their players out so arguably the ruck has ended. I'm not sure where the offside line is in such instances but they appear to line up parallel with the foremost opposition player. So in practice, perhaps 2m downfield from where the halfback picks up the ball.
By the time the ball gets to the oppo first five Chch defense is over the advantage line.
Really makes it difficult to impossible to get go forward from slow ball.
My gut tells me the offside line needs to be moved further back, but not sure exactly how to achieve that.
Maybe make it 5m back from front of first oppo player at the ruck which was?
5m gaps are very hard to police and would end up with lots of debatable calls. I thought that interpretation they tried of being 'clearly onside' rather than 'clearly offside' worked well. It wouldn't stop good ruck management defence like that you describe but it made a very clear method for the AR to identify those small half steps that make a big difference in these situations.
(I'm not complaint about anything in this game here just discussing the offside line topic)
