Ultimate NPC: - Auckland
-
@African-Monkey said in Ultimate NPC: - Auckland:
S. McDowellDowd- S. Fitzpatrick
- O. Brown
- A. Haden
- R. Brooke
- J. Kaino
- M Jones
- Z Brooke
- O. Tonu'u
- G Fox
- B. Williams
- S. Tuitupou
- J. Stanley
- J. Kirwan
T. WrightMils
Need to finalise a team. This one by @African-Monkey is close, just made a couple of changes
Dowd because McDowell is with BOP?
Mils over Wright? (Specialist plus a more recent player probably helps in voting)Any objections?
-
-
@Bovidae said in Ultimate NPC: - Auckland:
Let's hope the random draw gives some interesting 1st round matchups.
Cantabs v Auckland in the first round is a disaster for the broadcasters, but provides hope for all others.
Especially if the winner subsequently draws Otago
-
-
-
I went for Spencer earlier. Thought the consensus was against him
Fuck it. Spencer it is
- C. Dowd
- S. Fitzpatrick
- O. Brown
- A. Haden
- R. Brooke
- J. Kaino
- M Jones
- Z Brooke
- O. Tonu'u
- C. Spencer
- B. Williams
- S. Tuitupou
- J. Stanley
- J. Kirwan
- M. Mils
-
@dogmeat said in Ultimate NPC: - Auckland:
@Duluth nothing to really fear in the backline but the forwards are a bit tasty.
I would have Carlos over Fox personally. I think Foxy would too if he was being honest
I wouldn't, and I'm a huge Carlos fan, but as I think I said earlier Fox is a winning 10. To me this team is picked on how they were in the era they played. Carlos was one of two top 10s, Fox dominated the position for most of his career.
-
-
-
-
@Nepia because Botica supposedly couldn't kick - then kicking tees were allowed and he started banging them over from everywhere.
Fox's strengths were his mental fortitude and game management - he wasn't the most gifted 1st 5 but he made the most of what talents he did have. You should hear him talk about his son. Yes he is a proud Dad but he is totally bemused as to why Ryan isn't out practicing 12 hours / day.
-
@Duluth Solid side.
Just as an aside. In the mid 70's TV polled every NPC player in NZ and asked them one question - Who is the most over-rated player in NZ rugby. The 'winner' by some margin B.G Williams
I checked and Pole Whiting did play NPC so I would throw him in ahead of R Brooke for two reasons. One; I think he is a better player and Two; he's not a creepy sex offender
-
@dogmeat said in Ultimate NPC: - Auckland:
@Duluth Solid side.
Just as an aside. In the mid 70's TV polled every NPC player in NZ and asked them one question - Who is the most over-rated player in NZ rugby. The 'winner' by some margin B.G Williams
I checked and Pole Whiting did play NPC so I would throw him in ahead of R Brooke for two reasons. One; I think he is a better player and Two; he's not a creepy sex offender
if they drop BG they put Rokocoko in
it's frankly unfair.
-
@dogmeat said in Ultimate NPC: - Auckland:
Just as an aside. In the mid 70's TV polled every NPC player in NZ and asked them one question - Who is the most over-rated player in NZ rugby. The 'winner' by some margin B.G Williams
Before my time. I left him in from that other xv because I assumed old people would complain
Happy to pick a modern winger.. who?
-
@mariner4life said in Ultimate NPC: - Auckland:
if they drop BG they put Rokocoko in
He'll do.
Didn't play much for Auckland because of the modern NPC availability. Worthy of a spot
- C. Dowd
- S. Fitzpatrick
- O. Brown
- A. Haden
- R. Brooke
- J. Kaino
- M Jones
- Z Brooke
- O. Tonu'u
- C. Spencer
- J. Rokocoko
- S. Tuitupou
- J. Stanley
- J. Kirwan
- M. Mils
-
@Duluth said in Ultimate NPC: - Auckland:
@mariner4life said in Ultimate NPC: - Auckland:
if they drop BG they put Rokocoko in
He'll do
and today's award for biggest understatement goes to...
