2019 under 20's
-
@barbarian said in 2019 under 20's:
From the report of the Judiciary: red card upheld; high tackle; low-end offending
This incident was not a shoulder charge under the “Framework for High Tackles”. At the moment of contact the Player’s arms were moving forward as he attempted to grasp the player. It is, however, a high tackle as there was direct contact by the Player’s right shoulder to the throat and neck area of Eng #7. The Player was attempting a dominant tackle and there was some force involved in this contact. There may have been other contact between the players and in particular the Player’s left shoulder near the ball as well. There was no definitive contact to Eng #7’s head. Given the direct contact to the throat and neck area with force and a high degree of danger, a red card is warranted in this situation. The Player had the opportunity to make a lower tackle in the circumstances. The Player has failed to satisfy the onus on him to show, on a balance of probabilities, that the referee’s decision to issue a red card was wrong.
The Committee found this to be low-end offending which carries a two-week entry point. They reduced this to one week based on the player’s clean record, remorse, age, apology and conduct at the hearing. Tafa is suspended for the semi-final on Monday 17 June but free to play thereafter. -
HIGH RISK CONTACT TECHNIQUE WARNINGS
There's quite a list of players who have received such a warning. Only one Kiwi.
The following players received High Risk Contact Technique Warnings arising from match-day three under the trial in operation at the World Rugby U20 Championship 2019 with respect to upright tackles which result in contact with an opponent’s head: * Leicester Fainga'anuku (New Zealand No.11) Coaches now have the opportunity to review the player’s tackling technique to the satisfaction of the Citing Commissioner in order to have the first warning removed from the players’ records. Two Technique Warnings in the tournament will result in a one-match suspension. -
Now the game is stopped, because of the lightning.
Thunderstorm interrupting the game. The first time I see that during a tournament.
As we don't know how long this will last, I'm going to catch some
Will watch the rest of the game from the replay.
28': NZ 0 - 5 Wales
-
F Me. We lost to Wales U20?!
Italy will be licking their lips.
-
They were pretty dire. Dropped balls, missed passes, dumb penalties & gave turn-overs with abandon.
Was only in the last 15 mins they asserted themselves and got ahead - which they then threw away with poor discipline
-
Has been a dire under 20 campaign full stop. Seemed to me they looked arrogant like they are living on past glory of teams.
Will be interesting what comes out of this, if we want to compete we need to probably play more games like Sth A who do tours to NH. Can’t see us centralising system.
Every 3 or so years we will have great teams full of talent like 2015, 17 but I’m not sure how many of these players will kick on, as Mr Philpott says it should be judged on!
Australia making final they will be loving it and hopefully for them will kick on to national team. -
had heard from someone in the know that the team was lacking in a number of areas a month or so back, turns out he was on the money.
-
I decided to go back over the NZ Under 20 team that won the World Cup in 2017 to track how many players have gone to play Mitre 10 Cup rugby and on to play Super Rugby.
By my reckoning and I stand to be corrected of the 28 originally selected 18 have gone on to play super rugby (John JP Sauni) who has played for the Warratahs the rest having all played Mitre 10 Cup..and I still reckon several who have not played super rugby still have an opportunity moving forward.
Even the 3 that were unavailable have gone on to play super rugby with Jordie Barrett, Dalton Papalii & Asafo Amua becoming All Blacks
It’s not a bad bench mark if you think about it , a very well selected team even without the 3 that were unavailable..
Just on a footnote,Stephen Perofeta replaced Tiaan Falcon who was injured for the final..I had a nephew in this team so extremely proud as a uncle what they achieved .
It will be really interesting to see how many in this years team go on to Mitre 10 Cup rugby ,super rugby or even All Black Rugby..
Be interesting to hear your feedbackI know when the 2017 Baby Blacks flew in ,I was at the airport to meet the team , I ended up having a really good chat to NZ Rugby CEO Steve Tew..he told me during our conversation if they got a strike rate of around 45% that ended up playing Super Rugby and the rest playing Mitre 10 Cup ,that would be a real success moving forward .
Asafo Aumua Wellington
Sam Caird Waikato
Adrian Choat Auckland
Tom Christie Canterbury
Ryan Coxon Waikato
Tim Farrell Hawke’s Bay
Alex Fidow Wellington
Luke Jacobson (C) Waikato
Ezekiel Lindenmuth Auckland
Marino Mikaele-Tuu Hawke’s Bay
Dalton Papalii Auckland
Jacob Pierce Auckland
John (JP) Sauni Auckland
Samuel Slade Auckland
Pouri Rakete-Stones Hawke’s Bay
Isaia Walker-Leawere Wellington
Backs
Caleb Clarke Auckland
Ereatara Enari (VC) Canterbury
Braydon Ennor Canterbury
Tima Faingaanuku Ta$man
Tiaan Falcon Hawke’s Bay
Will Jordan Ta$man
Kemara Hauiti-Parapara Wellington
Orbyn Leger Counties Manukau
Josh McKay Canterbury
Jona Nareki Otago
Tamati Tua Northland
Thomas Umaga-Jensen Wellington
Players unavailable for selection:
Jordie Barrett Taranaki
Stephen Perofeta Taranaki
Peter Umaga-Jensen Wellington -
I'm not sure of the structure or rules - is it possible we could be demoted and not have automatic entry to the next competition if we finish badly enough?
-
@98blueandgold said in 2019 under 20's:
Has been a dire under 20 campaign full stop. Seemed to me they looked arrogant like they are living on past glory of teams.
Will be interesting what comes out of this, if we want to compete we need to probably play more games like Sth A who do tours to NH. Can’t see us centralising system.
Every 3 or so years we will have great teams full of talent like 2015, 17 but I’m not sure how many of these players will kick on, as Mr Philpott says it should be judged on!
Australia making final they will be loving it and hopefully for them will kick on to national team.I don't get the "arrogant". Who was arrogant? Maybe the coaches, but I didn't see arrogance (or complacency, if that's what you really mean) from the players. I didn't see anyone "living on past glory". Can you give a few examples, because I haven't seen it?
I saw mostly ineptitude. First and foremost from the coaches, who didn't select the best possible team and didn't seem able to come up with a good game plan.
Also lack of skills and too many handling errors from players, which in the last game can be partially blamed on the wet weather, but can also be due to whatever they have been doing or not doing during training; and obviously, some players not being good enough. However, in this respect it must be pointed out that I have seen bad ball handling from players who have shown plenty of skill during last year's Mitre 10 Cup, like Tupaea, Proctor, Gregory etc.
What has been most noteworthy is the lack of game management. The team was without a pivot capable of changing things up when something didn't work. Why did Burke get so much game time? He can't steer the ship or kick. I haven't seen the rest of tonight's game yet, so don't know whether Reihana got game time, but if he has been injured for the last two games, why didn't they call up McClutchie (or Trask)? If this campaign was about developing NPC or SR players (and not about winning the tournament), the failure of reaching the top 4 isn't an excuse for not calling in reinforcements in case of injury.
There are also several players in this team who haven't lost the schoolboy habit of going for glory themselves instead of passing to team mates; I saw impatience and maybe lack of faith in fellow players (sometimes justified, but no excuse for impatience). Particularly Funaki and McLoad were guilty of this in the backline. That's a coaching issue, too!
My fellow Magpies supporters on the Fern will recognise what is happening from our dark years under Philpott. It was depressing, and visibly sapping the confidence out of players, who looked scared to take the field, particularly in 2017 (Philpott's last year). Fortunately, they stuck around and one season under a new, good coach worked a treat. I have no doubt that several of the players that didn't perform during this NZU20s campaign will end up playing NPC and SR. They'll bounce back and under the coaching of proper coaches and in well-oiled teams, they will improve their skills and the talent that they have will be further developed. And some players, who were picked without clearly having the talent, will either not play (much) Mitre 10 Cup and will hopefully moving on to a career outside rugby. They won't make it.
To finish with a response to @Steven-Harris comments and list, I don't know whether this year's group will reach the 45% strike rate.
Please, correct me if I made mistakes in this list. Of the current group I have bolded the names of players who have played SR or have SR contracts and italicized the names of players that have played Mitre 10 Cup:
Kaylum Boshier (Taranaki) – Vice-Captain (played for Taranaki in a "Heartland" Ranfurly Shield challenge, but IIRC no M10 Cup)
George Dyer (Waikato)
Samipeni Finau (Waikato)
Devan Flanders (Hawke's Bay)
Cullen Grace (Canterbury)
Kohan Herbert (Bay of Plenty)
Kianu Kereru Symes (Hawke's Bay) - Captain
Shilo Klein (Canterbury)
Jeriah Mua (Bay of Plenty)
Fletcher Newell (Canterbury)
Ollie Norris (Waikato)
Simon Parker (Waikato)
Taine Plumtree (Wellington)
Kaliopasi Uluilakepa (Wellington)
Tupou Vaa’i (Taranaki)
Tamaiti Williams (Canterbury)Fergus Burke (Canterbury)
Leroy Carter (Bay of Plenty)
Leicester Faingaanuku ( Ta$man/Crusaders)
Cole Forbes (Bay of Plenty)
Taufa Funaki (Auckland)
Scott Gregory (Northland/All Blacks Sevens)
Lalomilo Lalomilo (Bay of Plenty)
Dallas McLeod (Canterbury) – Vice-Captain
Billy Proctor (Wellington/Hurricanes)
Rivez Reihana (Waikato)
Etene Nanai-Seturo (Counties Manukau/Chiefs)
Quinn Tupaea (Waikato) - has a development contract at the ChiefsOf this list, I can see some players progressing to SR level (partially based on what I've seen during M10 Cup):
Kereru-Symes
Plumtree
Williams
Gregory
Tupaea
and maybe LalomiloIf this assessment is correct, that would be a strike rate of 36%.
A few more will make it to Mitre 10 Cup level, but clearly, not enough.
Now, just imagine if they had selected Trask, McClutchie and Toala instead of Burke, McLeod and Forbes. All three have played Mitre 10 Cup, one has played SR and the two others might play SR in future. That would have lifted the strike rate to ...46%. And their inclusion would likely have lifted the team to a better performance, too.
-
@Stockcar86 said in 2019 under 20's:
I'm not sure of the structure or rules - is it possible we could be demoted and not have automatic entry to the next competition if we finish badly enough?
Every year, the lowest ranked team gets demoted to the WR U20 Trophy tournament, and the winner of the WR U20 Trophy tournament gets promoted to the WR U20 Championship. So this year, either Fiji or Scotland will get demoted. The WR U20 Trophy tournament takes place from 9 to 21 July 2019. Not sure whether the demoted team can already participate in that tournament or whether they have to wait until next year.
