AFL 2024
-
@mariner4life said in AFL 2024:
AFL Fans: That touched goal ruined our season!!! that should never happen in the modern age with all the available technology!! this is an absolut disgrace and further proof AFL House hates my club
Also AFL fans: The goal reviews are out of control and destroying the flow of the game. Why do we have so many? AFL House hates the game.
This is what you get when you listen to the whingers
I'm consistent. Across all sports. Video replay technology has done nothing for any of the games i like that it has been brought in for. And it hasn't decreased whinging, cries of conspiracy or bias, all its done is shift it from the guy on the field to the guy in the booth.
Fuck all of it off.With you here. 100%. Perfection in officiating is unattainable*, and any attempt to try and move closer has been unsuccessful.
AFL is a chaotic sport that is almost impossible to officiate. The rules are greyer than grey (none moreso than holding the ball), and umpires have to watch a million things going at warp speed. I don't blame the goal umpires for being gun shy after what happened in Adelaide.
One minute Richo is saying 'if you've got the technology, use it', and the next he's asking umpires to 'just get on with the game'. They can't win.
*Unless your sport involves black-and-white, in-or-out calls like tennis and to some extent cricket.
-
-
@mariner4life said in AFL 2024:
@barbarian said in AFL 2024:
to some extent cricket
i don't trust hawkeye
No, neither. But I trust hotspot, snicko and side cameras to adjudicate on runouts.
-
i hate footy again.
Lol at St Kilda
Collingwood are back
Carlton impressive in running over the Giants
Fuck Brisbane, fuck our spud talls. Fuck our inability to change styles when required. We're going to nowhere this season.
West Coast smashing Freo is hilarious. Suddenly there is hope at the Eagles
Sydney got themselves back on track, and the GC suffered a set back
And the West Coast result makes North's smashing look even worse. North might be fucked forever, because i imagine there will be compromised drafts for Tassie coming up, and North are absolute shit with no hopeEssendon and the Dogs are in the 8 at the moment, but i expect both to fall out, the other 6 ca start thinking about September.
St Kilda, West Coast, Adelaide, Richmond, Hawthorn, North Melbourne are already looking towards next year after 6 games.
The only reason Brisbane aren't joining that list is, We've played Carlton, Freo, Collingwood, Melbourne and Geelong already, we must be due the soft part of the draw. But we're only a week or two from writing everything off for the year. Terrible fucking season of terrible fucking performances. -
mods feel free to lock this thread
-
Adelaide lost this weekend yet?
-
I feel Norths are trying to steal our draft picks
-
@antipodean said in AFL 2024:
I feel Norths are trying to steal our draft picks
I'd celebrate, but it's only North Melbourne.
-
the hawks might be rubbish but that was pretty ruthless from the swannies...basically coasting the final quarter
-
At this stage the flag winner will come from Geelong, either of the Sydney teams, and maybe Carlton or Melbourne. No one else has the game to beat these 5 teams.
Everyone else is seriously flawed and making up the numbers -
i know there have been grand finals with two interstate teams (Sydney v West Coast)...but it would be interesting if there was two sydney teams that made the final
-
Oh i can hear the cries about academies and compromised drafts already
-
when its really a sign the draft works, sydney were 15th and 16th in 2019 and 2020....GWS 15th in 2022...so have used their draft picks well
-
I don't think there's the same level of negative feeling about GWS that there was in 2019.
Their bulk draft picks have come and gone (to other clubs, in many cases) and this team has ridden out a very brief down cycle and emerged better. They've recruited smartly with guys like Jesse Hogan and developed later round picks like Tom Green.
I recall before the GF in 2019 there was plenty of talk about a hollow win if they got up, but I can't imagine any of that would be replicated this year. They are seen as gritty underdogs now.
-
this comp is even weirder than the NRL
This weekend Carlton, Geelong and GWS lost. Port also lost but i didn't see them as a contender.
Of the "maybe we can sneak the 8" crew the Suns and the Bulldogs had embarrassing lossesEssendon currently sit in the falsest 5th you've ever seen, they have had the softest draw to start you could possibly imagine.
-
the Bloods keep marching on!
....as i keep falling down the tipping table....
-
Apparently Sydney are the only team that wants to be good.
Geelong lost at home to the going nowhere Port
GWS lost to the going nowhere Bombers
Melbourne gave to big a start to Carlton and couldn't run them down
Brisbane and Adelaide sort of fucked each others seasons by drawing.The bottom of the table is awful, and yet somehow St Kilda lost to Hawthorn.
Looking at the 8 now, i can't see any other team forcing their way in
-
@Kiwiwomble said in AFL 2024:
the Bloods keep marching on!
....as i keep falling down the tipping table....
the Bloods keep marching on!
....as i keep falling down the tipping table....
