Chiefs 2021
-
-
-
@gt12 said in Chiefs 2021:
The Chiefs were already fucked, so him having a little rest might be good for the ABs.
Trask will now get more time in the no.10 jersey I assume. Who played at fullback in the 2nd half? Tiatia or Stevenson? I didn't see the game.
-
@bovidae said in Chiefs 2021:
@gt12 said in Chiefs 2021:
The Chiefs were already fucked, so him having a little rest might be good for the ABs.
Trask will now get more time in the no.10 jersey I assume. Who played at fullback in the 2nd half? Tiatia or Stevenson? I didn't see the game.
You lucky bastard.
-
@crucial said in Chiefs 2021:
@gt12 said in Chiefs 2021:
The Chiefs were already fucked, so him having a little rest might be good for the ABs.
Three weeks, for that, seems heavy to me though.
It is the standard now and I agree that it needs to be there to try and change mindsets.
However, when one player gets 3 weeks yet another doesn't even get cited for a swinging high shot that connects flush on the chin it does look harsh.
I get why the ref missed it but the post game review should have easily cited that one.Which swinging high shot are we talking about?
-
@frye said in Chiefs 2021:
@crucial said in Chiefs 2021:
@gt12 said in Chiefs 2021:
The Chiefs were already fucked, so him having a little rest might be good for the ABs.
Three weeks, for that, seems heavy to me though.
It is the standard now and I agree that it needs to be there to try and change mindsets.
However, when one player gets 3 weeks yet another doesn't even get cited for a swinging high shot that connects flush on the chin it does look harsh.
I get why the ref missed it but the post game review should have easily cited that one.Which swinging high shot are we talking about?
To'omua on Collins the next day.
-
@crucial said in Chiefs 2021:
@frye said in Chiefs 2021:
@crucial said in Chiefs 2021:
@gt12 said in Chiefs 2021:
The Chiefs were already fucked, so him having a little rest might be good for the ABs.
Three weeks, for that, seems heavy to me though.
It is the standard now and I agree that it needs to be there to try and change mindsets.
However, when one player gets 3 weeks yet another doesn't even get cited for a swinging high shot that connects flush on the chin it does look harsh.
I get why the ref missed it but the post game review should have easily cited that one.Which swinging high shot are we talking about?
To'omua on Collins the next day.
I take it he hasn't been cited?
-
@kiwiwomble said in Chiefs 2021:
@crucial said in Chiefs 2021:
@frye said in Chiefs 2021:
@crucial said in Chiefs 2021:
@gt12 said in Chiefs 2021:
The Chiefs were already fucked, so him having a little rest might be good for the ABs.
Three weeks, for that, seems heavy to me though.
It is the standard now and I agree that it needs to be there to try and change mindsets.
However, when one player gets 3 weeks yet another doesn't even get cited for a swinging high shot that connects flush on the chin it does look harsh.
I get why the ref missed it but the post game review should have easily cited that one.Which swinging high shot are we talking about?
To'omua on Collins the next day.
I take it he hasn't been cited?
Not that I've heard. It may have been looked at but dismissed as a YC only which doesn't seem in line with the DMac call.
-
-
-
@gt12 said in Chiefs 2021:
Mils made some good points on the breakdown - how does Reece’s much more intentional hit get yellow but Dmac gets Red (and 3 weeks!) and that’s not even considering the Toomua shot.
Not sure on the Toomua one as I've only seen it once. But isn't there a few difference's between Sevu's and DMacs?
Sevu was making a tackle that started below the head on the ball carrier and then travelled up to contact with the head.
DMac ran in to shoulder charge/body check a player without the ball and clocked him clean in the face with his shoulder.
Sevu could always argue he was trying to make a tackle and a rugby incident occurred. DMac can only argue he was trying to take the Reds player out and accidentally hit his face, rather than his body.
-
-
@toddy said in Chiefs 2021:
@gt12 said in Chiefs 2021:
That Chiefs loose forward trio is awesome. Hard to believe the loose forward trio they're playing against is even better.
Super rugby was awesome back then.
Shit Lauaki was a fucken tank.
RIP to him and JC.
-
@toddy said in Chiefs 2021:
@gt12 said in Chiefs 2021:
Mils made some good points on the breakdown - how does Reece’s much more intentional hit get yellow but Dmac gets Red (and 3 weeks!) and that’s not even considering the Toomua shot.
Not sure on the Toomua one as I've only seen it once. But isn't there a few difference's between Sevu's and DMacs?
Sevu was making a tackle that started below the head on the ball carrier and then travelled up to contact with the head.
DMac ran in to shoulder charge/body check a player without the ball and clocked him clean in the face with his shoulder.
Sevu could always argue he was trying to make a tackle and a rugby incident occurred. DMac can only argue he was trying to take the Reds player out and accidentally hit his face, rather than his body.
That's a good point. On the other hand the Reece hit was pretty much straight to the head with impact. In terms of actual danger, I wonder which is worse, and in the modern game players run into each other all the time, so incidents very similar to the Dmac one get missed a lot (btw the way, I think the RC is justified, I just don't get the inconsistency).
I think Mils was making the point that there is a big difference between the two penalties, especially when Toomua got nothing for his (8:40 in the video).
From 6:45 here, you can the discussion about all three.
