Magpies 2017
-
@billsy11 I agree 100% with you, and the Magpies weren't exactly the only team with a lot of Super Rugby players returning to the province late. I seems, the only responsibility they are taking is for not organising a camp!
I do agree that the trialled law changes were bad for teams without big, strong loosies (like the Magpies); the only one remotely fitting that description was young lad Mikaele-Tu'u but he was only 18, inexperienced and mostly played with the U19s. I remember that commentators were saying during one of the Magpies games that we had the smallest/lightest pack of all 14 teams. But that's also something that can be fixed with good recruitment ...
IMO the changed laws were particularly bad for halfbacks, but I doubt it has much to do with the halfback's height (Weber is 1.75m) and more with their job description.
Btw, big/bigger halfbacks: Leon Fukofuka (1.9m, Auckland), TKB (1.87m, Waikato), Billy Guyton (1.86m, Ta$man), Jimmy Cowan (1.86m, Southland), Stratton (1.85m, Canterbury), Bryn Hall (1.83m, N Harbour) and Jono Ruru (1.83m, Otago).
The smallest midgets are Tipuna (1.70m, BOP) and Kayne Hammington (1.70m, Manawatu). -
The rule on overseas players is that if they can't be selected for the All Blacks then they are considered overseas players. So, Tony Lamborn, Tim Nanai-Williams, Digby Ioane etc all count as overseas players even though they were born here, because they are no longer All Black eligible. Its the same with the guys who play Japanese rugby in the super rugby offseason, like Cory Jane, Tanerau Latimer and Tamati Ellison a few years ago. Because they are signed up during the international window, they can't play for the All Blacks during that time so they are considered overseas players.
Interestingly, Sam Lousi is not an overseas player because he was born in New Zealand and hasn't played international rugby for another country. Eligible for All Blacks = Not overseas.
Also, there is no minimum or maximum number of overseas players a team is allowed. Teams have to ask the NZRU for dispensation for every overseas player on a case-by-case basis. They have to say which player they want to sign, what role they want him for, and they have to prove that there are no other available players in New Zealand that can fill that role. The Highlanders were able to show that there wasn't enough prop depth, so they could sign Halanukonuka and Geldenhuys as well as having Tanaka. Then when they had wing injuries they were able to show that English capped Jack Wilson was the only suitable replacement, giving them 4 overseas players.
In the case of Lamborn, Jane is the Hurricanes only overseas player, but the Hurricanes weren't able to make the argument that there were no other NZ qualified options for his role. As good as he is, he was just a squad looseforward for the Hurricanes and there are tons of them to go around, Bedwell-Curtis for instance is arguably just as good and he has only just got his first super rugby contract this year, probably as a result of Halafihi being bumped up opening a spot somewhere else.
Also, Ricciteli to Taranaki is all but a done deal, along with Jordie Barrett.
-
@reginald8 said in Magpies 2017:
The rule on overseas players is that if they can't be selected for the All Blacks then they are considered overseas players. So, Tony Lamborn, Tim Nanai-Williams, Digby Ioane etc all count as overseas players even though they were born here, because they are no longer All Black eligible. Its the same with the guys who play Japanese rugby in the super rugby offseason, like Cory Jane, Tanerau Latimer and Tamati Ellison a few years ago. Because they are signed up during the international window, they can't play for the All Blacks during that time so they are considered overseas players.
Interestingly, Sam Lousi is not an overseas player because he was born in New Zealand and hasn't played international rugby for another country. Eligible for All Blacks = Not overseas.
Also, there is no minimum or maximum number of overseas players a team is allowed. Teams have to ask the NZRU for dispensation for every overseas player on a case-by-case basis. They have to say which player they want to sign, what role they want him for, and they have to prove that there are no other available players in New Zealand that can fill that role. The Highlanders were able to show that there wasn't enough prop depth, so they could sign Halanukonuka and Geldenhuys as well as having Tanaka. Then when they had wing injuries they were able to show that English capped Jack Wilson was the only suitable replacement, giving them 4 overseas players.
In the case of Lamborn, Jane is the Hurricanes only overseas player, but the Hurricanes weren't able to make the argument that there were no other NZ qualified options for his role. As good as he is, he was just a squad looseforward for the Hurricanes and there are tons of them to go around, Bedwell-Curtis for instance is arguably just as good and he has only just got his first super rugby contract this year, probably as a result of Halafihi being bumped up opening a spot somewhere else.
Also, Ricciteli to Taranaki is all but a done deal, along with Jordie Barrett.
Thanks for that info. I trust your info is correct, but it's absolutely ridiculous that a player is considered to be an overseas player only because he plays for another country. Tony Lamborn wasn't just born here but is also a NZ citizen and that doesn't seem to mean anything only because he's no longer eligible for the ABs. Don't know about Digby Ioane, but I assume TNW has a Kiwi passport as well. As I've said before, I hope Lamborn - when he decided to accept the invitation from the USA Eagles - knew/was told that would make him an overseas player and put his spot in the Canes squad at risk.
Had totally forgotten that Lousi was born in NZ!
Arrggghhhh about Riccitelli, but he didn't play at hooker for us anyway. Hope Dixon is still good for a few more years; Tangaere is reasonably good, but we will eventually need a better player to replace Dixon.Just hope that lad from the HB Saracens won't become the third hooker; thought he was terrible during preseason. First priority for the frontrow should be a decent LH prop though, and TH if Edmonds doesn't return to fitness.
-
Yeah its pretty shit, there have been a lot of NZ born and bred citizens that have declared for PI teams and then had to swiftly move to the NH. The NZRUs reasoning is that the All Blacks are the number 1 priority and the Super Rugby teams only exist in essence to strengthen the All Blacks. The NZRU pays the salaries of all the Super Rugby players and they don't want to pay and develop players for other nations, at the expense of an All Blacks qualified player who could be in that spot. Its also there as a warning to players not to declare for other nations.I see the logic, but its pretty cutthroat. Lamborn would be foolish if he didn't know, its fairly common knowledge and he has to have an agent that let him know. On the plus side if any Hurricanes loose forwards get injured or Blade Thompson doesn't come back from concussion hes probably allowed straight back in given that he knows the systems and its a pretty easy argument to make.
As for Riccitelli, you can see why he left as he was never really a prop. He can cover there but if hes going to go on to higher honours its going to be at hooker and theres no chance for him to play there in the bay.
-
@reginald8 said in Magpies 2017:
Yeah its pretty shit, there have been a lot of NZ born and bred citizens that have declared for PI teams and then had to swiftly move to the NH. The NZRUs reasoning is that the All Blacks are the number 1 priority and the Super Rugby teams only exist in essence to strengthen the All Blacks. The NZRU pays the salaries of all the Super Rugby players and they don't want to pay and develop players for other nations, at the expense of an All Blacks qualified player who could be in that spot. Its also there as a warning to players not to declare for other nations.I see the logic, but its pretty cutthroat. Lamborn would be foolish if he didn't know, its fairly common knowledge and he has to have an agent that let him know. On the plus side if any Hurricanes loose forwards get injured or Blade Thompson doesn't come back from concussion hes probably allowed straight back in given that he knows the systems and its a pretty easy argument to make.
As for Riccitelli, you can see why he left as he was never really a prop. He can cover there but if hes going to go on to higher honours its going to be at hooker and theres no chance for him to play there in the bay.
Yeah, although Ash Dixon comes off contract at the Highlanders in 2017, turns 29 next year and may well opt to play overseas. If Riccitelli goes, and Dixon as well, the Magpies are really in the shit. Or maybe I should say, "the Magpies are even more in the shit".
-
Very good news:
Both Jonah Lowe and Mason Emerson have re-signed with the Magpies for 2 more years (2017 and 2018).
Also the following players have signed Pro-Zone (academy) contracts with the HBRU, which will prevent them from being picked up by other unions:
Hastings Boys High School
Lincoln McClutchie (1st five 8th)
Danny Toala (fullback)
Folau Fakatava (halfback)
Jacob Devery (hooker)
Kianu Kereru-Symes (prop)Napier Boys High School
Al Momoisea (winger)
Mitch Drew (center)Victoria Uni
Will Tremain (openside flanker)
Tim Farrell (LH prop)http://www.nzherald.co.nz/hawkes-bay-today/sport/news/article.cfm?c_id=1503460&objectid=11790162
-
@Stargazer Yeah this is good news. Both Lowe and Emmerson are very good players. I personally like Lowe on the wing. Great to see the young talent from the Schools being contracted as well. Hastings boys, what a year they had. I just hope we do sign some experienced players to not only help these guys come through but also after last year it's badly needed.. Gareth Evans please don't get hurt your badly needed. That No 8 last season in my opinion showed he was a converted sevens player. Good ball skills but at the breakdown and defensively sadly lacking. However hopefully fingers crossed lessons learnt.
-
@billsy11 Yes, it would be great to have Evans for a whole season, after 2 seasons ruined by serious injury. A talented young player like Marino Mikaele-Tu'u could learn a lot from him, although physically they couldn't be more different (Mikaele-Tu'u is huge). Mikaele-Tu'u will probably feature in the NZ U20s again this year. I agree with what you say about Selesele, he didn't impress on defence.
Personally, I really hope they will be able to attract a few good props (our pack was one of the weakest and lightest of the 2016 season). I saw on instagram that Tolu Fahamokioa is back in Tawa (Wellington), so I'm not sure whether he'll be available for the Magpies again this year (not sure whether he has moved back to Wellington permanently). He hasn't really convinced at LH, but he was still better than Jason Long or Mark Braidwood. I think Mason Kean is a TH? Not sure at which side young Pouri Rakete-Stones plays, but he's also in the NZ U20 frame. These young lads need an experienced player to learn from and we can't be sure Edmonds will play again. We'll also need a new hooker; although not officially announced, I assume Riccitelli has signed with Taranaki. Just relying on Dixon, Tangaere and a development player would be stupid.
We also need another loosie. I didn't really rate Hamelink last season. With the trialled laws abandoned, Lamborn should have a better season this year though. Fingers crossed.
Our midfield definitely needs an experienced player. After losing Horrell, Guildford and Buckman in the backs last year, we've now also lost Fruean and Tongia. I don't see West and Weber as leaders in the backline, so we desperately need a Super Rugby player to take on that role. I also keep my fingers crossed that Gillies Kaka will return to the Magpies. We desperately need a good fullback with Dagg most likely to be unavailable. If Kaka returns, I'd like to see McNicol on the wing and Lowe in the midfield, the latter shifting to the wing if one of the wings goes down (McNicol seems to be very injury prone).
I hope the HBRU will be more proactively searching for good, new players this year. Last year, the hiring and the firing was terrible and the late, season-ending injuries to many players didn't help either.
With the new tackle laws introduced, I also hope that there will be a big focus on that area during club rugby this year. I'm still disappointed they didn't use the trialled laws last season. That hurt the Magpies big time.
-
@Stargazer I agree with most of what you say. I personally wouldn't mind if Ben May came back. The other prop you mentioned from Wellington is in my opinion a useful player when fit. Kean im not sure about. Edmonds hopefully can play again. Buckman may be back. (Here's hoping). Kaka would be very welcome. McNicholl if he shrugs off injury and concussion problems would also be an asset. Definitely need a midfielder. We seen to be ok at lock with 3 super rugby players. Filipo please don't come back..Hooker assuming Riccitelli has gone to Taranaki is another area. I'm not at all sold on our back up. All in all the wallet needs the moths shaken off it. Oh and please Chris Eaton ( great servant that you've been) please retire. Ellery Wilson is a much better option.
-
-
Expectations/fears confirmed: Riccitelli has signed with Taranaki for 2 years. Ash Dixon better not get injured/leave, because our current selectors suck at finding replacements (in time). Hope they prove me wrong though ...
Any candidates you can think of?
Taranaki Rugby
The official website of Taranaki Rugby and the Yarrows Taranaki Bulls. Inspiring Taranaki. Enriching Lives.
-
@Stargazer Hikare Forbes was dam good value when he was here. Would only be 30 so he'd be worth while. And let us not forget Hika, he'd jump at the chance. But can Mike Bishop swallow his stupid pride and ask.
-
@billsy11 Not sure whether we should have two top dogs in Ash & Hika. I don't think we should go for a 2nd hooker, who is older than Dixon, unless we can't find a good 2nd hooker, who is younger than 28. Tangaere is 22-23 years old.
Is it Bishop who should swallow his pride, or the head coach, or some board members?
How long has Bishop been the CEO now? And how long have we had the same board? If those board members keep on being nominated for re-election by the clubs (or whoever nominates them), you can't expect much innovation and new ideas.
I don't know what the problem/cause is, but we've had so many Super Rugby players the last few years. We should perform much better than some other Mitre 10 Cup teams with more club players, yet we don't. We should be well-established in the Premiership, but we have been relegated again. They must be doing something wrong, and with "they" I mean the coaches, (other staff?) & decision-makers, not the players. Something needs to change.
-
@Stargazer We would be getting a 1st hooker with Hika ....
It's Bishop and head coach that would need to swallow their pride re: Hika. (Anyway, I can't see it happening now). What's Sam Anderson-Heather up to these days?
-
Lock Geoff Cridge has been ruled out for the season after having knee surgery post Hawke's Bay's Mitre 10 Cup campaign ...Some people have no luck! Injured again & will miss the Super Rugby season. Hopefully, he'll be fully fit for the Mitre 10 Cup.
Good to see that Jonah Lowe, Tiaan Falcon & Hugh Renton are all starting for the Canes in their first preseason game, with Mason Emerson and Mark Abbott on the bench. Has Renton already played for the Canes? I remember Cridge making his debut last year, but can't remember whether Renton also earned his first cap or was injured all season. Anyway, Canes debut for Lowe, Falcon and Emerson. Will be a good experience for them, even if their stay with the Canes ends after preseason.
-
The non-Wellington Hurricanes have been allocated to local clubs.
The Magpies have been allocated as follows:
Old Boys-University: Hugh Renton, Ben May (both Hawkes Bay)
Poneke: Mark Abbott (Hawkes Bay)
Wellington: Jonah Lowe (Hawke's Bay)I wonder whether the fact that Lowe is on this list means that the Canes have extended his temporary contract?
Hurricanes in club rugby this season
Above: Hurricanes prop Loni Uhlia, the Tongan Bear, playing for Marist St Pat's last year. The WRFU has released its list of allocations to clubs of non-WRFU contracted players in the Hurricanes for the 2017 season...
-
The young lad is being noticed, by the Canes coaches but also now by the media. Still not sure whether this means that Jonah now has his short-term Canes contract extended though.
Out of King's College and with a New Zealand under-20 campaign behind him, plus the award as Hawke's Bay's best back in 2016, Lowe is an interesting outside back option as the Canes await the playing return of Julian Savea from his off-season. "Jonah has gone really well. He is a late inclusion in our squad. He had a good game against the Blues last weekend and he, like a number of other people, will be keen to knock down the door to get them further up the pecking order," says Hurricanes head coach Chris Boyd.http://www.nzherald.co.nz/sport/news/article.cfm?c_id=4&objectid=11798670
-
@Stargazer said in Magpies 2017:
The non-Wellington Hurricanes have been allocated to local clubs.
The Magpies have been allocated as follows:
Old Boys-University: Hugh Renton, Ben May (both Hawkes Bay)
Poneke: Mark Abbott (Hawkes Bay)
Wellington: Jonah Lowe (Hawke's Bay)I wonder whether the fact that Lowe is on this list means that the Canes have extended his temporary contract?
Above: Hurricanes prop Loni Uhlia, the Tongan Bear, playing for Marist St Pat's last year. The WRFU has released its list of allocations to clubs of non-WRFU contracted players in the Hurricanes for the 2017 season...
Yes, Jonah will remain with the Hurricanes to end of 2017 campaign. Be interesting to see how much game time he might get.
-
@Number-10 said in Magpies 2017:
@Stargazer said in Magpies 2017:
The non-Wellington Hurricanes have been allocated to local clubs.
The Magpies have been allocated as follows:
Old Boys-University: Hugh Renton, Ben May (both Hawkes Bay)
Poneke: Mark Abbott (Hawkes Bay)
Wellington: Jonah Lowe (Hawke's Bay)I wonder whether the fact that Lowe is on this list means that the Canes have extended his temporary contract?
Above: Hurricanes prop Loni Uhlia, the Tongan Bear, playing for Marist St Pat's last year. The WRFU has released its list of allocations to clubs of non-WRFU contracted players in the Hurricanes for the 2017 season...
Yes, Jonah will remain with the Hurricanes to end of 2017 campaign. Be interesting to see how much game time he might get.
He posted a photo on instagram with the text "Pre seasons finally over.. Time to run on the waters ✔️#waterboy #thirsty"
I'm afraid that waterboy will indeed be his main role this season, until and unless injury strikes .. A bit like Wes Goosen last year? Just hope he'll be able to show enough to get a contract for next year. Would also be awesome if he could make the Maori ABs or the Barbarians (provincial) team to play the Lions, but competition for a spot will be fierce ...
