Other Cricket
-
@Cyclops yeah, I imagine his strike rate for his last year or 2 was probably closer to 150 though. Damn he was exciting to watch open the batting at that time.
-
@KiwiPie said in Other Cricket:
Bert Sutcliffe's 385 really is a crazy scorecard
From memory that was the highest first class score by a left handed batsman as well..until that 'so so' batsman from the West Indies did ok..
-
@No-Quarter said in Other Cricket:
@Cyclops yeah, I imagine his strike rate for his last year or 2 was probably closer to 150 though. Damn he was exciting to watch open the batting at that time.
From the start of 2015 he played 27 ODIs and his strike rate was 154.91.
-
hey @Chris any insight in to whether or not Ussie just wanted the weekend off to go to the motor racing, not really expecting Qld to need him again this season?
-
@mariner4life said in Other Cricket:
hey @Chris any insight in to whether or not Ussie just wanted the weekend off to go to the motor racing, not really expecting Qld to need him again this season?
Yeah phantom hammy Qld cricket pretty pissed off,
I can’t say too much but no record of any injury.
That I know for certain.
Ussie is a top bloke though really down to earth . -
-
@MN5 Pommy social media site aimed at lads under 25.
Can't take it seriously when they include Dhoni. Must have a lot of Indian subscribers.
Despite their records I wouldn't have Kallis or Lara in a top 10 either. As for Iron Bottom - almost as much of a joke as Dhoni.
-
@dogmeat said in Other Cricket:
@MN5 Pommy social media site aimed at lads under 25.
Can't take it seriously when they include Dhoni. Must have a lot of Indian subscribers.
Despite their records I wouldn't have Kallis or Lara in a top 10 either. As for Iron Bottom - almost as much of a joke as Dhoni.
You’re dead to me……..
In terms of a mercurial individual I can’t think of anyone better than Lara ( number one on this list the obvious exception)
Beefy is worth a mention for the first half of his career in which he was pretty untouchable. He should have retired around 1987 or so though……
Dhoni is the obvious ridiculous call here….
Also the complete and utter lack of fast bowlers.
-
@MN5 said in Other Cricket:
You’re dead to me……..
It's top 10 of all time. It could be there aren't sufficient superlatives to describe a player and he still misses out.
I think I have found where ladsbible got that list from. The BBC did a poll to coincide with the 2019 CWC (shame it was cancelled)
If you look at the list below its a complete lift
Listeners of the Beebs Asian Networkvoted for their favourite from a shortlist of 30 players compiled by a panel of experts, including Radio 1 DJ and co-host of 5 Live’s Tailenders Greg James, former English cricketer Isa Guha, IPL host Shonali Nagrani, and Asian Network’s Noreen Khan.
Hardly surprising then that
-
nearly half come from the subcontinent
-
apart from Bradman and Sobers all played at least some of their career during the last 30 years or so
-
there's three Poms that you could definitely argue against
-
-
In comparison here's Wisden's 5 players of the Century.
The Don
Garfield Sobers
Jack Hobbs
Shane Warne
Viv RichardsPretty sure those 5 are locked in, hard to argue with any of those
Dhoni is super laughable, hes lucky to be top 10 Indian player of all time let alone World Top 10. -
@dogmeat said in Other Cricket:
@MN5 said in Other Cricket:
You’re dead to me……..
It's top 10 of all time. It could be there aren't sufficient superlatives to describe a player and he still misses out.
I think I have found where ladsbible got that list from. The BBC did a poll to coincide with the 2019 CWC (shame it was cancelled)
If you look at the list below its a complete lift
Listeners of the Beebs Asian Networkvoted for their favourite from a shortlist of 30 players compiled by a panel of experts, including Radio 1 DJ and co-host of 5 Live’s Tailenders Greg James, former English cricketer Isa Guha, IPL host Shonali Nagrani, and Asian Network’s Noreen Khan.
Hardly surprising then that
-
nearly half come from the subcontinent
-
apart from Bradman and Sobers all played at least some of their career during the last 30 years or so
-
there's three Poms that you could definitely argue against
Well yeah, Cook and Anderson impress with longevity more than anything.
I'm a Beefy fan, his final stats don't do justice to how amazing he was early in his career but it is hard to gauge if he should be there or not.
Dhoni ( previously mentioned ), Kapil Dev, Chris Gayle and Jayawardene are taking the piss.
-
-
@Virgil said in Other Cricket:
In comparison here's Wisden's 5 players of the Century.
The Don
Garfield Sobers
Jack Hobbs
Shane Warne
Viv RichardsPretty sure those 5 are locked in, hard to argue with any of those
Dhoni is super laughable, hes lucky to be top 10 Indian player of all time let alone World Top 10.Those two had excellent records but others on paper were/are more impressive.
They're there for swagger, impact, charisma etc as much as anything.
-
@MN5 said in Other Cricket:
Well yeah, Cook and Anderson impress with longevity more than anything.
I'll give you Anderson but Cook played test cricket or 12 and a half years - Smith, Kane and Kohli have already had longer test careers than him. Kane will need to play another decade to pass Cook's total of tests.
-
@KiwiPie said in Other Cricket:
@MN5 said in Other Cricket:
Well yeah, Cook and Anderson impress with longevity more than anything.
I'll give you Anderson but Cook played test cricket or 12 and a half years - Smith, Kane and Kohli have already had longer test careers than him. Kane will need to play another decade to pass Cook's total of tests.
Good point. His claims are even more tenuous.
From his era or thereabouts I'd rate Hayden, Smith and Sehwag all arguably better than him.
-
For me Gilchrist has to be looked at, we'd never seen a keeper play as a batsmen like him before
Only negative consideration is hes not the best Keeper of all time. Its his batting that made him stand out
He's a big reason why OZ were so good in the early 2000's in both Tests and ODI's -
Anderson was England's Rigor. A limited player who fashioned a very good career through obduracy and making the absolute most of his limitations.
Off the top of my head better English openers would be Hobbs, Sutcliffe, Hutton, Gooch and Boycott.
Andersons in the second tier with guys like Vaughan, Edrich and Strauss who were of a similar ilk
