• Categories
Collapse

The Silver Fern

S

SouthernMann

@SouthernMann
About
Posts
2.9k
Topics
9
Groups
1
Followers
0
Following
0

Posts

Recent Best Controversial

    WR U20 Championship 2025
  • S SouthernMann

    @Landers92 said in WR U20 Championship 2025:

    Yup, Mathis has played 6 a couple of times for his club in Christchurch. Mixed in with one game at 7 and another game on the wing.

    He will be a really useful acquisition for the Crusaders next year.


  • 2025 All Blacks v France series
  • S SouthernMann

    Normally embargoed copies get sent around to media about now. With a 5 AM announcement. I think I remember


  • School Rugby 2025
  • S SouthernMann

    Saw the Southland U16 boys training squad. 41 players from SBHS. Talk about a one school union.


  • NZ Club Rugby 2025 ( General)
  • S SouthernMann

    A few video highlights from Dunedin Club Rugby. Things looking very grim down there.

    Link doesn't appear to be working. Go to Otago Community Rugby on Facebook.


  • 2025 All Blacks v France series
  • S SouthernMann

    Don't the stats basically say he misses one tackle a game? Which over the course of the six games he played means he only missed seven tackles. Small sample size.


  • 2025 All Blacks v France series
  • S SouthernMann

    @nostrildamus said in 2025 All Blacks v France series:

    @brodean said in 2025 All Blacks v France series:

    I'd suggest Caleb Tangitau needs to work on his defensive workrate and accuracy. Based on these Carter would seem a better option that Tangitau for test rugby.

    and this article says Carter is the fastest

    All Blacks coach Scott Robertson reveals who the fastest player in New Zealand is

    All Blacks coach Scott Robertson reveals who the fastest player in New Zealand is

    All Blacks head coach Scott Robertson has revealed who the fastest player in New Zealand is, and it's not one of his current squad members.

    But didn't look very settled to me in his last game.

    The fastest would be Michael Manson. He just doesn't have the other necessary components to support his speed.


  • WR U20 Championship 2025
  • S SouthernMann

    Just going back to the 2019 squad. Which finished 7th. Plenty of players have developed well out of it. Poor performance at U20s level doesn't mean guys should be totally written off.

    admin_hland  /  May 8, 2019  /  RugbyHeartland News

    NZ Under 20 squad named for World Rugby Under 20 Championship - RUGBY HEARTLAND

    NZ Under 20 squad named for World Rugby Under 20 Championship - RUGBY HEARTLAND

    New Zealand Under 20 squad named for World Rugby Under 20 Championship


  • WR U20 Championship 2025
  • S SouthernMann

    Temperature of 29c. With a feels like 34c. That is some nasty rugby playing conditions.


  • NPC 2025
  • S SouthernMann

    @SouthernMann said in NPC 2025:

    @taniwharugby said in NPC 2025:

    @SouthernMann said in NPC 2025:

    John Leslie never got a chance either.

    Up here either, it felt like he was head coach here in name only with others pulling the strings and then got turfed at the 1st corner.

    He comes across as a very smart bloke. May have too many opinions for the blackheads managing the unions/clubs he has been involved with.

    There is an issue for coaches somewhat coming in for short term roles, or having to undertake double roles at unions.

    They are often

    • Given no ability to pick players from club rugby

    • Players have already been confirmed month in advance

    • the balance between player development and board/commercial partners wanting a winning team, looking for a bandage solution to get there

    • balancing the books around maintaining players and keeping within budget

    These guys aren't just getting to coach.


  • NPC 2025
  • S SouthernMann

    @taniwharugby said in NPC 2025:

    @SouthernMann said in NPC 2025:

    John Leslie never got a chance either.

    Up here either, it felt like he was head coach here in name only with others pulling the strings and then got turfed at the 1st corner.

    He comes across as a very smart bloke. May have too many opinions for the blackheads managing the unions/clubs he has been involved with.


  • NPC 2025
  • S SouthernMann

    @Steven-Harris said in NPC 2025:

    @SouthernMann he’s been likened to Wayne Smith just watched his post match interview says heaps about culture and belief he’s able to empower on teams
    I doubt wether he will be at the Taniwha for long can see Martin ending up at a Super franchise sooner rather than later

    One of his quotes from this mornings post match interview
    “We recruit for character and train for skill “

    Too often we want to push coaches quickly up. Martin basically started with kids progressing his way up. His coaching has matured with years of experience and learning through the development of players at different stages.

    NPC coaching gigs are not well paid. It must be tough to work out how to make a career of it. Martin is a coaching mercenary, going where the opportunities and money are.

    Some of the older coaches are balancing commercial other enterprises. While the younger former professional player coaches probably have some financial stability to be able to take a part-time approach to the role.


  • NPC 2025
  • S SouthernMann

    @Steven-Harris said in NPC 2025:

    Northland head coach Ryan Marin picks up his 3rd MLR title in a row
    Rivez Reihana has mentioned to a few people that Martin is the best coach in terms of attack planning he has had in his career and has helped him improve his own game

    Which makes me quite pissed off at Otago/Highlander systems. The guy came through as OBHS first XV, Otago Assistant and had to move away to get ahead. We seem to produce some really decent coaches in Dunedin. Yet the decision makers constantly make the incorrect call. Jamie Mackintosh is another example. John Leslie never got a chance either. Seilala Mapusua the same.


  • Highlanders 2026
  • S SouthernMann

    @Smudge said in Highlanders 2026:

    @SouthernMann said in Highlanders 2026:

    Force makes sense for Hastie. Grew up there until 2019. Played first XV with Tamati Williams over there. Its first string halfback getting on. Would he have already done the Australian residency?

    What I'm frustrated about is that we haven't seen it announced who is leaving the franchise yet

    Sad thing is he's one of the few Logan Park High School-adjacent rugby players we could claim.

    His dad was the standout loosie for LPHS in the early 1990s.

    Otherwise it's Flilipo Levi, who switched to Otago Boys in 7th form, or Shane Stewart, who played for Ulster about 25 years ago.

    LPHS the home of Sparkie Dickel. Fuck all else in the sports arena. The only Dunedin school that can claim a current national talk back radio host though.


  • Highlanders 2026
  • S SouthernMann

    @frugby said in Highlanders 2026:

    The way it works, is they will not announce players leaving who have not yet signed elsewhere. Standard practice.

    No it isn't. The last two years two to three weeks after the season they have released a list.


  • Highlanders 2026
  • S SouthernMann

    Force makes sense for Hastie. Grew up there until 2019. Played first XV with Tamati Williams over there. Its first string halfback getting on. Would he have already done the Australian residency?

    What I'm frustrated about is that we haven't seen it announced who is leaving the franchise yet


  • 2025 All Blacks v France series
  • S SouthernMann

    @brodean said in 2025 All Blacks v France series:

    @antipodean said in 2025 All Blacks v France series:

    My impression is he doesn't do enough in the defensive side of the game.

    Lasaqa doesn't hit enough rucks for a 7 and is ineffective:

    Rucks Per 80 Minutes
    35.34 Dalton Papali'i
    32.44 Tom Christie
    31.48 Du'Plessis Kirifi
    29.13 Jahrome Brown
    28.53 Ardie Savea
    26.84 Luke Jacobson
    26.31 Kaylum Boshier
    20.92 Veveni Lasaqa

    Attacking Ruck Effectiveness
    89.9 Dalton Papali'i
    89.6 Tom Christie
    87.6 Jahrome Brown
    86.3 Ardie Savea
    85.0 Du'Plessis Kirifi
    84.9 Luke Jacobson
    76.5 Veveni Lasaqa
    76.1 Kaylum Boshier

    Defensive Ruck Effectiveness
    23.5 Kaylum Boshier
    23.2 Luke Jacobson
    21.5 Du'Plessis Kirifi
    20.5 Ardie Savea
    15.2 Jahrome Brown
    14.5 Dalton Papali'i
    13.8 Tom Christie
    12.1 Veveni Lasaqa

    Be interested to see Sean Withy's stats there. Lasaqa spends a lot of time in the wider channels. With Withy primarily being the worker. It is Lasaqa's first year in Super too. He will get better, bigger and more robust.


  • 2025 All Blacks v France series
  • S SouthernMann

    @zedsdeadbaby said in 2025 All Blacks v France series:

    Well this makes the loose forward mix for the first test very interesting.

    It would be perhaps unlikely Jacobson will play too.

    So are we looking at Finau, Kirifi, Savea with Lio-Willie off the bench?

    Or does Vaii start at six..


  • NZ Cricket
  • S SouthernMann

    The spring and autumn of cricket


  • Otago 2025
  • S SouthernMann

    Apparently he isn't based in Dunedin yet.


  • Highlanders 2026
  • S SouthernMann

    Looks like Filimone saying thanks and goodbye as well.

  • Login

  • Don't have an account? Register

  • Login or register to search.
  • First post
    Last post
0
  • Categories
  • Login

  • Don't have an account? Register

  • Login or register to search.