All Blacks v Wales Test #3

No Quarter

Moala did his chances of taking that bench spot in TRC no harm at all, seems like a great option there. Pace and power for impact and covers 11 - 14. 
I really hope Ngatai finds his feet at international level as I'm super excited about a SBW-Ngatai combo. Otherwise I'd take SBW-Crotty. Still think Fekitoa has a lot of work-ons, seems like exactly the same player as whem he first hit the scene, lots of rough edges.

canefan

<blockquote class="ipsBlockquote" data-author="Disgusted of TW" data-cid="591865" data-time="1466882866">
<div>
There's over one million signatures on an online petition to try to overturn the EU referendum. I reckon if they added "rescinding the new contracts offered to Howley and McBryde" to the list of demands, they might get even more signatures.
</div>
</blockquote>
They must have done because now it's 2M

canefan

I'm still rooting for Naholo to come good but I'm not sure putting a guy who is suspected of having tits for hands in the midfield was the best way to showcase his talents

booboo

<blockquote class="ipsBlockquote" data-author="nzzp" data-cid="591881" data-time="1466888247"> 
Law 22 <a class="bbc_url" href="http://laws.worldrugby.org/?law=22">http://laws.worldrugby.org/?law=22</a> 
There are two ways a player can ground the ball: (a) Player touches the ground with the ball. A player grounds the ball by holding the ball and touching the ground with it, in in-goal. â€˜Holdingâ€™ means holding in the hand or hands, or in the arm or arms. No downward pressure is required.<a class="bbc_url" href="http://laws.worldrugby.org/content/video_popup_ver6.php?v=laws/2366-grounding">1<img src="http://laws.worldrugby.org/images/elements/video.png" alt="video.png"></a><a class="bbc_url" href="http://laws.worldrugby.org/content/video_popup_ver6.php?v=laws/2367-grounding">2<img src="http://laws.worldrugby.org/images/elements/video.png" alt="video.png"></a> (b) Player presses down on the ball. A player grounds the ball when it is on the ground in the in-goal and the player presses down on it with a hand or hands, arm or arms, or the front of the playerâ€™s body from waist to neck inclusive</blockquote>
 
Bugger off with your facts and laws. Even though it confirms what I said. Much more fun to speculate wildly based on half forgotten memories...

hydro11

<blockquote class="ipsBlockquote" data-author="hurricane" data-cid="591798" data-time="1466858963">
<div>
No 
Consistency in selection is a hallmark of All Blacks policy over the past gazillion year's. We always respect the incumbents until they stop performing 
in the test match arena, Fekitoa and Crotty were higher on the pecking order and deserved to start the series. 
Our selection policies make our players know where they stand and give the players security. 
Also I thought his performance was mixed. Overall yes he gets an 8 out of 10 and looks promising. But there was a bit of hungus about his play. 
On his first line break he delayed his pass too long and then the moment was lost. Secondly on his first missed try he should have shovelled it along 
the line or drawn and passed. 
My humble opinion only.
</div>
</blockquote>
 
They picked Seta Tamanivalu off of a handful of Super Rugby games ahead of Moala. Moala was the best player for the Blues last season, played well in Samoa and was playing good rugby before the international break. I'm sure Hansen & co had their reasons but I can't understand what they were right now.

Hooroo

Well the Naholo at center works if second five skip passes center to wing. Couldn't catch for toffee.

ACT Crusader

<blockquote class="ipsBlockquote" data-author="canefan" data-cid="591888" data-time="1466890238">
I'm still rooting for Naholo to come good but I'm not sure putting a guy who is suspected of having tits for hands in the midfield was the best way to showcase his talents</blockquote>
Shades of Toeava. Now where's davidav....

DMX

<blockquote class="ipsBlockquote" data-author="ACT Crusader" data-cid="591911" data-time="1466896115">Shades of Toeava. Now where's davidav.... :)</blockquote>
 
I agreed with Davidav on that one. Toeava physically and skill wise had the potential to be one of the greatest AB backs ever, but mentally just could not cut it imho, error count is what killed him.

Frank

Naholo is (relatively) mistake free at Super level. But he seems to be trying too hard.

KiwiMurph

All Blacks were wonderful but it was a bit of a perfect storm - our game style under the roof at Dunedin vs a Welsh team with limited athletes at the end of a long season - it was always on the cards.
 
It is great watching the skills of the ABs under the roof - the pace at which they play, the ball skills - a real joy to watch.
 
Thought Barrett was excellent - best test at 10 he's played by far - not just his running and passing game but areas where he isn't so strong - field kicking and goal kicking - were good too. Will be interesting if he can push forward with the Canes and claim the 10 jersey for the Sydney test.
 
Dagg again excellent. I'm not sure I get the argument that Ben Smith HAS to be at fullback - Dagg on full form like he is at the moment has some wonderful abilities, and probably some areas where he is possibly even better than Smith (defensive high ball take, punting distance) - and Ben Smith is an exceptional winger - an argument could be made he's an even better test winger than fullback - plus they have an excellent combo so they should keep rolling with Dagg 15 Ben Smith 14 in my opinion.
 
Savea - He did get better as the game went on but he still looks a long way off of the player from 2012-14. It's going to be particularly interesting to see how he goes for the Canes, same with Naholo for the Highlanders, they could be fighting for the 11 jersey in Sydney. 
 
Moala showed a lot to like and a lot to work with moving forward - he definitely needs to work on his decision making, when to pass, but after making breaks but he really does pose some questions for the defence, he straightens terrifically, is powerful, has good feet and good short area acceleration. He was up against a quality centre opponent too. His defence was good too. I'd like to see him get opportunities at Rugby Championship at both 13 and 23 as bench impact covering 11/12/13/14. He's shown more than Seta and in my opinion looks to offer more than Fekitoa, but it is a small sample size.
 
Thought Dixon showed good intent, got up off the line and got stuck in. Squire was terrific - you can see why the selectors like him - he's a good athlete, has good size and is abrasive. There's really good loose forward impact off the bench with him and Ardie. Ofa T was solid when he came on, was impressed with him at scrum time (as I was with Charlie), didn't disgrace himself.
 
I think the Sydney test is going to be really interesting - who knows what will happen with injuries/form between now and then, Wallabies will be getting players back from Europe and will likely have a bit longer to prepare as they are unlikely to have players involved in Super Rugby final. Could definitely see a Wallaby ambush in Sydney again, and ABs don't have a great record in Aus of late but i'd like to think the ABs will be better prepared for Cheika-ball than last year.
 
Edit - and on another note - the commentators were again woeful - my personal favourite - after Naholo goes on, Marshall then gets surprised when Naholo goes to centre, then says "I've just been told Naholo played centre at school" - Hansen specifically mentioned all of this in the press conference - that Naholo would be covering centre and that he played there in schoolboy rugby - is it too much to ask that Marshall at least watches the AB press conferences during the week for preparation for a job he gets paid to do?

taniwharugby

Dagg calls out hungus BB...
 
<a data-ipb='nomediaparse' href='https://www.tvnz.co.nz/one-news/sport/rugby/he-just-hungus-israel-dagg-explains-beauden-barretts-try'>https://www.tvnz.co.nz/one-news/sport/rugby/he-just-hungus-israel-dagg-explains-beauden-barretts-try</a>

MN5

Agree Kiwimurph, between Marshalls stupid comments and Nisbo getting more mundane and dull by the season I wouldn't mind a real shake up in the Comm box.
 
Surely Moala has leap frogged, well at least Taminuvula and possibly the as yet unsighted Ngatai. Say what you want about the tired Welsh team, he was still up against one of the better midfield combos and shone beautifully. I don't see Fekitoa as having the jersey by rights just cos he did the apprenticeship under Nonu/Smith/SBW.

Frank

Perhaps Moala to start at left wing and be given some time to come into the centers later in the game.
 
Fekitoa is in his 3rd season with the ABs - looks exactly the same player as when he started.
 
Crotty - solid journeyman - always will be.
 
NMS might struggle to start with Dagg in that form, as I don't think he plays left wing and Hansen probably wants one power winger.
 
Barrett might have earned the start ahead of Cruden provided he continues to take on the line and not just shovel it on (as well as achieving parity with Cruden in goalkicking).
He is bigger and quicker than Cruden - me likey
 
I think Hansen will have his eye on Akira Ioane as an impact sub for the EOYT, and perhaps even his younger brother.
 
The performances of Ardie Savea and Cane suggest they are pretty close. I think Ardie should be given a start at some point so he is not permanently cast as the impact sub.
Cane had a poor first half yesterday but was solid enough thereafter. I am yet to see him have a breakout game for the ABs. Hope he hasn't been anointed too soon because he is so mature and responsible (and doesn't have a silly haircut)
 
Like Squire more than Dixon.
 
Romano - meh
 
Let's hope Ofa can actually scrum better and that wasn't just a tired Welsh front row because he has big upside.
 
The lack of minutes given to Codie Taylor suggest the selectors see Harris as in number 2. (guess)
 
Welcome back 2011 Dagg, it's been a while. Loving the terrible mustache.

Chris B.

<blockquote class="ipsBlockquote" data-author="Frank" data-cid="591967" data-time="1466913134">
<div>
Perhaps Moala to start at left wing and be given some time to come into the centers later in the game.
 
Like Squire more than Dixon.
 
The lack of minutes given to Codie Taylor suggest the selectors see Harris as in number 2. (guess)
</div>
</blockquote>
 
Yeah - I'm wondering whether they shed Tamanivalu for the Rugby Championship and keep George as a "designated" wing - maybe at the expense of DMac, or maybe Savea.
 
Even though Squire is a good Ta$man boy, it's a pretty small sample size to conclude that. Liam still has a few rough edges to knock off, but he looks like yet another one who won't be playing much for the Mako$ in the future.
 
I think the main conclusion about hooker is that Coles is quite a long way ahead of the other two. Pretty sure he played more than 70 minutes in every match. I guess given that Harris got 1st dibs and got two tests to one he's probably in the number two slot, but I'd think it's far from decisive. Neither got much chance to show their wares. Hooker suddenly looking pretty strong with Coles in his prime and both the young guys with heaps of potential.

nostrildamus

<blockquote class="ipsBlockquote" data-author="DMX" data-cid="591915" data-time="1466896882">
<div>
I agreed with Davidav on that one. Toeava physically and skill wise had the potential to be one of the greatest AB backs ever, but mentally just could not cut it imho, error count is what killed him.
</div>
</blockquote>
Nah, he got shifted around like billie-oh. And he was a FB or 12. Should have been allowed to choose one.

hydro11

If Barrett was to start at 10 we could pick McKenzie on the bench and leave Sopoaga out of the squad all together with Cruden as the third 10. I personally think Sopoaga does offer something off the bench but it is an idea.

canefan

<blockquote class="ipsBlockquote" data-author="hydro11" data-cid="591980" data-time="1466917001">
<div>
If Barrett was to start at 10 we could pick McKenzie on the bench and leave Sopoaga out of the squad all together with Cruden as the third 10. I personally think Sopoaga does offer something off the bench but it is an idea.
</div>
</blockquote>
He's composed so we need not worry about him steering the cutter come squeaky bum time. It allows Shag to move BB back to 15 if he wants, to take advantage of the greater space and the tiring opposition. McKenzie's time will come

Bones

Oh yeah - Naholo disappointing. You hope to see players stop making the same mistakes across a series. But saw Shag rubbing his nose a couple of times during the game, at Naholos loose carrying and poor handling, also at Crottys kicking.

canefan

<blockquote class="ipsBlockquote" data-author="Frank" data-cid="591916" data-time="1466897272">Naholo is (relatively) mistake free at Super level. But he seems to be trying too hard. </blockquote>Some guys make the transition to AB level look reasonably easy. Others struggle, Feki and Naholo have looked out of their depth in black so far

nzzp

<blockquote class="ipsBlockquote" data-author="nostrildamus" data-cid="591979" data-time="1466915793">
<div>
Nah, he got shifted around like billie-oh. And he was a FB or 12. Should have been allowed to choose one.
</div>
</blockquote>
 
I was watching a replay of the 2010 Wales game. Toeava was playing on the wing and was, frankly, phenomonal. Size, speed, skills - except for his handling. Woulda coulda, shoulda, but would have loved to see him and Piutau playing for Auckland at the same time.

The Silver Fern

All Blacks v Wales Test #3