RWC QF: France v South Africa
-
@Machpants said in RWC QF: France v South Africa:
@voodoo said in RWC QF: France v South Africa:
@MajorRage said in RWC QF: France v South Africa:
Surely the WC chokers tag can never be applied to us now after this weekend of semi-finals ...
Gutted for France. But they didn't deserve it, the Boks did.
> Amazing that Kolbe'e charge down was the difference.
Boks with an awesome backline is a scary prospect. Kolbe was unreal tonight
I said at the time that it was amazing that we didn't see a single replay to confirm whether he left early or not - other providers may have, but you'd think that would be the easiest thing for a TMO to quickly check? We check every other bloody thing!
Just cos we don't see it didn't mean it was not checked by the TMO, they do their work on their screens, not ours
Which is awful. I know they want to keep the game moving but for fans it's just a massive mystery what's going on in the background.
I would prefer slower games but more transparency. But broadcasters must love this.
-
@KiwiMurph said in RWC QF: France v South Africa:
Given the tendancy of refs to swallow their whistle late you wonder if the French would have been better to go for the try instead of the kick with 8 mins or so left at that stage.
I was thinking the same thing when they went for the penalty kick,
That may be their last chance to get a head.
The Boks could close this out from the kick off . -
@Billy-Tell said in RWC QF: France v South Africa:
Gutted. Staying with my French mate who was also my best man. Really wanted fra vs nz final. Especially as we had tickets to 2007 and had to sit thru eng va sa.
Could have been worse. You could have had tickets to the Fr NZ quarter...
-
@mooshld said in RWC QF: France v South Africa:
But what killed them is a tiny winger given no help at all against bombs and chasers all a foot taller than him.
Bielle-Biarrey is taller than either Arendse or Kolbe, who coped just fine, and even out-jumped taller opponents. It was often the likes of Woki who didn't take a high kick cleanly.
Maybe it was mentioned in the previous match comments but Fickou ignoring his unmarked winger which would have given France a second early try was a big miss. Scoreboard pressure.
-
@Rancid-Schnitzel said in RWC QF: France v South Africa:
@sparky said in RWC QF: France v South Africa:
Kwagga Smith, what a player!
Very handsome fellow as well.
Judging by that metric it's no wonder Liam Williams was able to keep hold of the Wales 15 jersey for so long.
Terrific first half, second half more tense than quality. Still, very good game to watch, congrats SA, hard luck France.
-
Yeehah. French crowd taken out of it for the final. England could take the Boks now with the right ref. The choice of officials will be important for remaining matches. I thought BOK was great today and had respect of the players.
Feel sorry for Mauvaka and the ever dangerous Penaud. Jalibert was great too. My mom was Kolbe and that chargedown pretty much decided it in the end.
Great set of quarters! -
@Bovidae said in RWC QF: France v South Africa:
@mooshld said in RWC QF: France v South Africa:
But what killed them is a tiny winger given no help at all against bombs and chasers all a foot taller than him.
Bielle-Biarrey is taller than either Arendse or Kolbe, who coped just fine, and even out-jumped taller opponents. It was often the likes of Woki who didn't take a high kick cleanly.
Maybe it was mentioned in the previous match comments but Fickou ignoring his unmarked winger which would have given France a second early try was a big miss. Scoreboard pressure.
I'm saying once France realised he wasn't coping they needed to do something either change him or get help on those bombs. Just because the other team are coping doesn't mean you leave him to sort it himself. Coaches didn't react and France had no counter. Tactically brilliant by SA but real dumb by France not to react.
-
@Machpants said in RWC QF: France v South Africa:
@voodoo said in RWC QF: France v South Africa:
@MajorRage said in RWC QF: France v South Africa:
Surely the WC chokers tag can never be applied to us now after this weekend of semi-finals ...
Gutted for France. But they didn't deserve it, the Boks did.
> Amazing that Kolbe'e charge down was the difference.
Boks with an awesome backline is a scary prospect. Kolbe was unreal tonight
I said at the time that it was amazing that we didn't see a single replay to confirm whether he left early or not - other providers may have, but you'd think that would be the easiest thing for a TMO to quickly check? We check every other bloody thing!
Just cos we don't see it didn't mean it was not checked by the TMO, they do their work on their screens, not ours
Maybe it was - but if it was us on the receiving end of that, I’d be pretty dark to not see the replay, and to not hear the ref confirm that the TMO had looked at it
-
Anyone else spot the subtle little nudge by Arendse on the French player under the garryowen for the first try. Arendse looking up at the ball, but he runs into the French player who knocks into his teammate (Fickou?) and the ball ricochets off. Arendse mops up the mess.
Would be interested to hear if anyone else thought it was interference.
-
The French were able to make huge in-roads through that SA defense all game, the problem was all the passing and offloads they kept running out of support, and lost ruck ball, either to turnover, or a panicked presentation that got knocked through.
Even that last possession they got off their line, made 60m easy, then one guy got isolated and tried to throw it back, South Africa pounced.
-
South Africa, you cruel bastards denying France a final in their own RWC. France were so dominant early on but the Boks just hung in there.
I think I prefer the Boks for the final, it's our turn against them, plus, France in a home final might have beaten us on passion alone. But, if we don't win I would have preferred France to win.
-
Dupont blaming the ref, classless fluffybunny
“There’s a lot of disappointment and frustration,” said the France captain. “When we watch the match again, there are probably things that will make us even more frustrated.
“I don’t want to be a bad loser and moan about the refereeing. But I am not sure the level of refereeing was up to what was at stake today … [But] that doesn’t take anything away from the South Africans. They played a great game.”
Too late, you tool. Fans can moan, you have to take it. Esp as BOK did bloody well - and I was supporting France for that game
-
@mariner4life said in RWC QF: France v South Africa:
The French were able to make huge in-roads through that SA defense all game, the problem was all the passing and offloads they kept running out of support, and lost ruck ball, either to turnover, or a panicked presentation that got knocked through.
Even that last possession they got off their line, made 60m easy, then one guy got isolated and tried to throw it back, South Africa pounced.
....pounced from an offside position
Agree about the French attack. It's great to watch them open opposition defences up but then frustrating as hell to see them not finish it off.
-
@mooshld said in RWC QF: France v South Africa:
@Machpants said in RWC QF: France v South Africa:
@voodoo said in RWC QF: France v South Africa:
@MajorRage said in RWC QF: France v South Africa:
Surely the WC chokers tag can never be applied to us now after this weekend of semi-finals ...
Gutted for France. But they didn't deserve it, the Boks did.
> Amazing that Kolbe'e charge down was the difference.
Boks with an awesome backline is a scary prospect. Kolbe was unreal tonight
I said at the time that it was amazing that we didn't see a single replay to confirm whether he left early or not - other providers may have, but you'd think that would be the easiest thing for a TMO to quickly check? We check every other bloody thing!
Just cos we don't see it didn't mean it was not checked by the TMO, they do their work on their screens, not ours
Which is awful. I know they want to keep the game moving but for fans it's just a massive mystery what's going on in the background.
I would prefer slower games but more transparency. But broadcasters must love this.
You are alone wanting a slower game and more replays etc I think. It makes no difference to us, the refs have decided so carry on. If any of us need a replay, generally tvs have a rewind button on the remote.
-
@sparky said in RWC QF: France v South Africa:
Well, we will just have to deal with the Big Bad Boks ourselves then.
Hmmm I am picking England to accumulate points in multiples of three and meet us in the final and English press to go crazy about how it was the right thing to get rid of Eddy
-
@Nevorian said in RWC QF: France v South Africa:
@sparky said in RWC QF: France v South Africa:
Well, we will just have to deal with the Big Bad Boks ourselves then.
Hmmm I am picking England to accumulate points in multiples of three and meet us in the final and English press to go crazy about how it was the right thing to get rid of Eddy
2007 all over again, where England look a bit rubbish but get the final?
-
@mariner4life said in RWC QF: France v South Africa:
The French were able to make huge in-roads through that SA defense all game.
No doubt Schimdt is taking notes because we don't seem to be able to do it.
