Wallabies v Springboks 1
-
Wow this is the gift that keeps on giving.
Burger blasts Kiwi referee
Former Test referee Freek Burger has highlighted the inconsistent calls from New Zealand referee Paul Williams following the Springboks' loss to the Wallabies in Adelaide.
Former Test referee Freek Burger has highlighted the inconsistent calls from New Zealand referee Paul Williams following the Springboks’ loss to the Wallabies in Adelaide.
In an interview with Sunday newspaper Rapport, Burger said that Wallabies wing Marika Koroibete should have been sent off for his try-saving tackle on opposite number Makazole Mapimpi.
“In my opinion there were no arms. Here we are talking about a red card, about a penalty try,” Burger told Rapport.Uh... yeah Freek - let's put the bottle down and have a little rest, eh?
-
-
@barbarian said in Wallabies v Springboks 1:
If I was a Springbok fan I'd be embarrassed at the state of that fanbase.
Yeah guys, it was the ref who cost you. Again. Must be such a fun way to watch rugby, hovered over your keyboard desperate for the first 50/50 call not to go your way.
Nothing has changed really there. I guess they are consistent.
Pretty impressive Wallaby performance IMO, they started absolutely fizzing.
-
This is a fairly interesting angle of it.
I'd ignore the point about "ONLY Koroibete's arm makes contact." that the poster is making.
I'm assume the no wrap people have problem with is the right arm? Which is where the problem of slowing down a video of 2 players moving at a 100mph down to 10mph comes in. IMO.
You have a guy lining up a runner who is haring for the corner, who then slows and cuts into the inside 'weak' shoulder, of course the outside arm isn't then going to be able to wrap around a player who is no longer in the space the 'computer' lined him up to be in.
The inside arm, (and the arm which connected to the shoulder which makes contact) does wrap. That's enough for me.
People getting targeted on the inside should who then don't wrap with both arms is as common as flies on turds. Just the position on the field and speed of the two players that is different (and the success of the inside weak shoulder/arm tackle).However, I do suspect Marika's league instincts were in full force there and if Mapimpi hadn't decelerated and cut in then Marika might have had a bad outcome.
https://www.reddit.com/r/rugbyunion/comments/x00dcj/it_legitimately_looks_like_only_koroibetes_arm/
-
@Kirwan said in Wallabies v Springboks 1:
@barbarian said in Wallabies v Springboks 1:
If I was a Springbok fan I'd be embarrassed at the state of that fanbase.
Yeah guys, it was the ref who cost you. Again. Must be such a fun way to watch rugby, hovered over your keyboard desperate for the first 50/50 call not to go your way.
Nothing has changed really there. I guess they are consistent.
Pretty impressive Wallaby performance IMO, they started absolutely fizzing.
It reminded me a bit of watching the Bledisloe, except we were NZ and SA were the Wallabies.
The Saffers played a lot of rugby and just couldn't breakthrough. We had only a few opportunities but took them ruthlessly.
In the end the game was over at minute 65 and the Saffers didn't know what happened.
-
-
@SidBarret said in Wallabies v Springboks 1:
@NTA dude when you quote a 30 year old game and a newspaper in a language you dont speak to prove how loud whinging is, maybe it isnt that loud
Huh?
-
@SidBarret said in Wallabies v Springboks 1:
The frustration is with a lot of big calls that were in referee discretion that didnt go our way, the high tackle on Lolesio VS the first Koriobete tackle on Vermeulen, the skew throw called against Dweba, the high tackle on Reight on the goal line, the second warning for maul offenses against Faainga, the Koriobete tackle, the de Klerk slap. Individually non of those calls were wrong per se, but we didnt get lucky, or were unlucky with how the chips fell in a lot of those cases. Had these 50 50 calls been split more evenly there would be far less complaints, but we wouldnt have won.
Ah yeah I doubt that.
-
@Rapido this discussion probably need to be moved off this thread because its not about the game, but rather about the laws but...
I don't see this wrap by the left arm that you are referring to. What see there is just a body check with Marika charging through the contact
-
@SidBarret said in Wallabies v Springboks 1:
@Rapido this discussion probably need to be moved off this thread because its not about the game, but rather about the laws but...
I don't see this wrap by the left arm that you are referring to. What see there is just a body check with Marika charging through the contact
joke, but open your other eye
Seriously, though, thsi kind of incident gets everyone polarised. Honestly, was just a great tackle, and enough of a wrap to get awy with it. Wrapping with your head on the wrong side is difficult.
But, this is modern rugby. Frame by frame analysis of a monster collision to save a try.
-
@nzzp said in Wallabies v Springboks 1:
@SidBarret said in Wallabies v Springboks 1:
@Rapido this discussion probably need to be moved off this thread because its not about the game, but rather about the laws but...
I don't see this wrap by the left arm that you are referring to. What see there is just a body check with Marika charging through the contact
joke, but open your other eye
Seriously, though, thsi kind of incident gets everyone polarised. Honestly, was just a great tackle, and enough of a wrap to get awy with it. Wrapping with your head on the wrong side is difficult.
But, this is modern rugby. Frame by frame analysis of a monster collision to save a try.
Was a brilliant tackle, he came from another city to make it too.
-
@MiketheSnow maybe he should have ruck him properly like in the old days.
-
-
@W32 said in Wallabies v Springboks 1:
What a strange game. It’s almost as if the boks have some sort of mental block, and give the Australians too much respect. If the bokke can’t win this weekend, I have very serious doubts about nienabers nous as a coach. Damn it!
Interesting stat about Boks winning rate without Rassie on the sideline, 36%
-
@Machpants said in Wallabies v Springboks 1:
Even the assistant ref was impressed by Marika tackle
looks 11 has managed an amazing judo move with his leg....
-
-
@NTA said in Wallabies v Springboks 1:
Wow this is the gift that keeps on giving.
Former Test referee Freek Burger has highlighted the inconsistent calls from New Zealand referee Paul Williams following the Springboks' loss to the Wallabies in Adelaide.
Former Test referee Freek Burger has highlighted the inconsistent calls from New Zealand referee Paul Williams following the Springboks’ loss to the Wallabies in Adelaide.
In an interview with Sunday newspaper Rapport, Burger said that Wallabies wing Marika Koroibete should have been sent off for his try-saving tackle on opposite number Makazole Mapimpi.
“In my opinion there were no arms. Here we are talking about a red card, about a penalty try,” Burger told Rapport.Uh... yeah Freek - let's put the bottle down and have a little rest, eh?
That Wobbly tackle technique gives new meaning to going for the ball?!
